News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:10PM (#11568694)
What are either of those statements based on?
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:20PM (#11568746)
Experience. There are tons of women in the workforce. It's unexceptional to the point you wouldn't even notice, even in tech.

If you read an article that said "Bob the mailman was beaten to death by local residents because he was good at his job" would you think "Yep, that sounds like the whole story"?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:49PM (#11568856)
She also had the audacity to do things like 'talk at conferences'.

In general, a good thing to do in lots of situations is listen to people about their lived experiences, and after listening to women talk about being in this industry for a while this sort of thing becomes just 'a particularly horrible example' instead of 'something totally incomprehensible.'

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:08PM (#11569163)
>She also had the audacity to do things like 'talk at conferences'.

Sure. That would be believable if the year were, say, 1850.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by cyphar on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:22PM (#11569210)
I don't really understand why you think that there was no harassment (or that Jessie deserved it or did something to rile the community against her). The solution to problems like this isn't to deny it. I've worked with her online for several years and she's an awesome hacker, and I'm not aware of anything she did to "deserve" being harassed.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by RealityVoid on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:26AM (#11570033)
I do not think that OP doubts the existence of harassment, I think he doubts the causes of it. The cause written, "this person received horrific threats because she's good at her job and out teaching others how to use an up-and-coming programming technology" does seem pretty unlikely.

On one hand, this comes off kinda' bad, as if we're looking for the real reason this person is being harassed, looking if they deserved it or not. No matter what prompted this harassment, this is wrong, terrible and should not happen to _anybody_ no matter the sex, position or actions of that person.

But, I still have my curiosity as to what reason these harassers might have. They might be simply sexist but that seems a little exaggerated, considering there are other women that have exposure and don't seem to suffer the same level of harassment. I enjoy greatly reading Julia Evans's posts for example, and I haven't seen signs of harassment over there - maybe I haven't been paying attention.

There might be something specific that this person did that made the harassers angry - I repeat, this is not to incriminate miss Jessie Frazelle, and she might not have done anything wrong, but something made the attackers angry, maybe something complety ridiculous. What would that thing be? If there is a thing this person did, this harassment might have originated even if she were a man. Maybe it's not such a sex thing after all? It seems there are plenty of public people that get death threats and are harassed, and these things are generally tailored to the sex of a person - women get killed an raped, men get killed and told to suck a dick.

I don't know, I'm just confused - it's true there aren't many women in tech, and I'm as welcoming as possible but there are certain issues that I don't understand and don't know how to approach, but trying to solve them requires actually understanding them beyond a short article and evasive tweets.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:46AM (#11570107)
For me the problem is that gozur88 "just doesn't believe" this, that the article seems "fishy" and that "experience" tells gozur that these things just-don't-happen in the post 1850 world. These are all the smells of an argument driven by an intuition prioritized over and above the real experiences of women in tech. Again and again we see this. The article that quantifies the amount of speaking roles in movies by gender, or if women have been sexually assaulted at work or not, excluded some datapoint, had one poorly stated point, didn't cover x or y or z, and therefore can be discarded. The problem is that no amount of evidence seems enough to please these people, and that any amount of links or anecdotes or documented cases seems to be discarded as cherry-picked. And the conclusion drawn is that the problem is overblown, and doesn't need to be addressed.

Its interesting to me that you mention Julia Evans. I've never encountered her writing, but she definitely has a belief in the truth of women's stories about harassment. See here: http://jvns.ca/blog/2016/03/06/women-only-spaces-are-a-hack/

Perhaps Julia would respond better to a direct e-mail asking her if she'd share any of her experiences in tech! Might be worth a shot?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by cyphar on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:23AM (#11570446)
> On one hand, this comes off kinda' bad, as if we're looking for the real reason this person is being harassed, looking if they deserved it or not.

Hence why I used scare quotes for "deserved". People don't deserve to be harassed.

As for "something that made the harassers angry", eh. I don't know. But that's not the point. The fact that people are so happy to create a toxic environment for other people is something we should address.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:31PM (#11569247)
What evidence do you have that makes you disbelieve this?
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:02AM (#11569571)
Have you never seen a woman speak at a conference? If so, did you see anybody threaten her?

Are you from Saudi Arabia?

Disbelief requires no evidence. It only requires a story that doesn't square with your experience. And this one definitely smells fishy.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:20AM (#11569612)
> Disbelief requires no evidence.

Interesting. So is Atlanta rapper BOB right to say the earth is flat because he's never observed its curve? He personally thinks the idea of earth as a globe is fishy.

Its funny, I'd say to him that his feeling of fishiness has no merit and that he should be forced to justify his claim of disbelief.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:57AM (#11569723)
Well, in the absence of any evidence the earth is round, it's perfectly reasonable for him to believe the earth is flat until he's presented with a plausible argument that it's round.

Have you ever been exposed to religion?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:28AM (#11570041)
So to draw a parallel to the current argument, are you claiming that no woman has been abused by a man simply for doing a better job than them?
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:52PM (#11575038)
By "a" man? Maybe. By multiple men? No.

Back to the religion thing... did you know God loves you and wants you to send me money? You don't really have grounds to disbelieve that, do you? I mean, facts and evidence?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:29PM (#11575816)
So your argument is that only one man (at a time, in a lifetime? unsure here) will attack a woman for this?

Earlier:

> Nobody gets harassed because they're good at their job and go out teaching others etc, etc.

The mental gymnastics you're doing to find a way to disbelieve this whole article are impressive. But ultimately, you're tripping over your own feet.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @08:02PM (#11576817)
Yes, I did say that. The point being there's always one crazy person in any large crowd. But you don't get a lot of people sending you ugly tweets just because you're contributing to a software effort.

The mental gymnastics you're doing to fit this into your world view are impressive. But it's really coming across as facile virtue signaling. You seem to be suspending rudimentary common sense in an effort to believe that which is unbelievable.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @08:51PM (#11577042)
You've used a lot of emotive words - like the article seems "fishy" or that you don't believe this article due to "experience" and now that believing this account defies "rudimentary common sense".

I can think of a lot of instances in which "common sense" has been invoked as short hand in an argument where the people involved simply can't explain why they disbelieve the opposition.

You seem to quite often attempt to signal that you are aligned with an unbiased and rational view, but you seem to just discard arguments based on your emotions.

There's been a few threads on this article that you've abandoned. Its becoming more and more clear its because you simply can't satisfyingly state the reasons for your judgements.

> But you don't get a lot of people sending you ugly tweets just because you're contributing to a software effort.

Again, source? Or is this another one we can tack down to "common sense".

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @06:06AM (#11579070)
>You've used a lot of emotive words - like the article seems "fishy" or that you don't believe this article due to "experience" and now that believing this account defies "rudimentary common sense".

"Fishy" isn't at all an emotive word. And of course I don't believe I used the word "rudimentary".

>You seem to quite often attempt to signal that you are aligned with an unbiased and rational view, but you seem to just discard arguments based on your emotions.

I'm not the one making emotional arguments. This is the situation:

  1.  Woman does her job very well.
  2.  ???
  3.  Harassment.
Obviously if step 1 is actually true there's a step 2. You want to be the white knight and protect her, emotionally. But that's infantilizing her.

>There's been a few threads on this article that you've abandoned. Its becoming more and more clear its because you simply can't satisfyingly state the reasons for your judgements.

That's silly. At this point you just keep repeating yourself without addressing anything I've written. Couple that with the timeout on HN they've added to discourage this conversation and it's literally not worth the trouble, so I'm going to end it here. Of course you're welcome to reply, though frankly I'll be very surprised if you include anything new.

>Again, source? Or is this another one we can tack down to "common sense".

Again, do I really need a "source" to explain to you people don't do things for no reason? Really?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Wednesday April 27, 2016 @07:03AM (#11579315)
> And of course I don't believe I used the word "rudimentary".

> You seem to be suspending rudimentary common sense in an effort to believe that which is unbelievable.

Maybe, just maybe, what you believe and what is actually true are two entirely different things.

Calm down.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @08:06AM (#11571095)
Are you assuming that these threats were in some kind of public sphere?
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:24PM (#11568762)
>Experience. There are tons of women in the workforce. It's unexceptional to the point you wouldn't even notice, even in tech.

Interestingly, noir_lord noticed and you can see that in his comments on this article. I have the impression that many, many people notice how exceptional and small the presence of women is in tech.

No news article has the "whole" story, so why single this one out? They are necessarily a digest of the events.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Monday April 25, 2016 @09:37PM (#11568803)
I'm singling this out because whatever they left out was critical to understanding the story.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Monday April 25, 2016 @10:01PM (#11568903)
Could you explain to me what critical information you feel is missing?
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by malandrew on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @07:20PM (#11576569)
The evidence that supports this statement:

"...this person received horrific threats because she's good at her job and out teaching others how to use an up-and-coming programming technology."

I'm not going to say it's not plausible that that is the reason like others are saying. Personally, I'm doubtful, but I'm willing to entertain that that actually is the reason.

Assuming that actually is the reason, what evidence supports that statement. Are there numerous troll comments that we can read with our own two eyes that unambiguously demonstrate that the trolls were motivated by her skill?

If there isn't, then I would expect the statement to be ""...this person received horrific threats."

Either there is evidence that supports the statement that begins with "because..." or there isn't. That evidence is clearly omitted.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Monday April 25, 2016 @10:38PM (#11569056)
The reason. If people are attacking her there's a reason. It might not be a good reason, but there's a reason.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Monday April 25, 2016 @11:04PM (#11569155)
But the article states what it thinks the reason is. You clearly think that reason isn't plausible. Could you help me understand what reasons you would find plausible?
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @12:50AM (#11569529)
>But the article states what it thinks the reason is.

Oh, does it? When you read this:

"...this person received horrific threats because she's good at her job and out teaching others how to use an up-and-coming programming technology."

it seems reasonable to you? Do people generally receive "horrific threats" because they're good at their jobs?

I don't see any point in speculating about what's actually going on here. It's pretty clear whatever it is isn't in the article, though.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:17AM (#11569600)
> Do people generally receive "horrific threats" because they're good at their jobs?

If by people you mean women, then yes.

You don't seem able to say exactly why you find this so hard to believe. Could it be that your experiences are limited?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @01:59AM (#11569730)
It could be. Probably not, at my age, but you never know.

More likely, the people reading this and assuming the root of the whole thing is, incredibly, a woman who's being attacked for doing a good job (and not being a tax collector or similar government functionary) are simply credulous.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:26AM (#11570031)
So the older a person is, the more their experience is likely correct? Turns out a lot of old people (the majority) oppose gay marriage. Do you feel like they are right?

Since there seem to be some people who believe the account in this article and others that don't, what in your mind is the experience that people have been exposed to that changes their minds?

It seems like you're saying they are purely irrational. Do you have any evidence which suggests that?

I'm really interested because so far you've provided no content to suggest why someone should join you in your incredulity.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by wjagodfrey on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:24AM (#11570448)
Right. Seriously Gozur, what experience are you going on? Listen to yourself man. "I don't think women get harassed for being women." That's utter bullshit. They do get harassed for it. Their gender. Nothing more. I've worked in the industry for over a decade, and women are never treated equally. They are never well represented. They are always judged more harshly than men are.

No matter what your age, you need an education.

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @08:08AM (#11571107)
Wait hold on a second here, are you saying being 'a tax collector or similar government functionary' is grounds for being attacked.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @03:51PM (#11575029)
Obviously not. But it might be a reason.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @05:31PM (#11575844)
The article states its reasoning, you choose not to accept it.

What reasons would you accept?

Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by gozur88 on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @07:58PM (#11576792)
What I would "accept" is irrelevant. All I'm saying is the reason the author provided is literally incredible.
Re:A Docker engineer got so many threats the company hired s... by tomlock on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @08:56PM (#11577053)
If you think the reason is incredible, it is precisely your incredulity and the reasons for it that are in question.

Even if reason is a concept that is outside of human control, you're still attempting to apply it to this article. It is necessarily channeled through you when you comment on this situation.

What you accept is relevant.