News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The ShapeShift Hack by btilly on Monday April 25, 2016 @03:59PM (#11566877)
So we've got three potential theories here.

1. ShapeShift has the right version of events.

2. Rovion is Bob who is having fun mocking and misleading the CEO, safe in the belief that he will never be caught.

3. Rovion is another insider who is providing himself with cover to blame Bob and an outside hacker if he's ever caught.

This post criticizes the first theory on Rovion's interaction not making much sense. And indeed it doesn't unless Rovion is a fairly weird guy.

The second theory makes some sense. By telling this yarn, Bob managed to steal two more times, while having all evidence of how he did it the second 2 times not being taken as leads to who he is now or what he is doing.

The third theory makes a ton of sense. Rovion can either be someone who was already planning to steal. Or just an insider who saw how easy it was and was motivated to do the same.

One interesting detail is that Bob's initial theft is just sitting in a wallet, untouched. So apparently he didn't need that money. The first theory would say because he got paid by Rovion and can wait. The second theory would say because he made 2 other withdrawals that he can use. The third theory leaves that open.

Based on human nature I'd rank them 3, 2, 1. Based on his leaving a bunch of money untouched, and my opinions about criminals, I'd rank the theories 2, 1, 3. Either way the CEO should be dubious about the story he was fed by "Rovion".

Re:The ShapeShift Hack by blakeyrat on Monday April 25, 2016 @04:53PM (#11567266)
I think you missed the insinuation at the end of the article:

4. The CEO faked the entire story (perhaps using Bob or Rovion or both as patsies-- or perhaps taking the money for himself) because the same money-stealing "we learned our lesson" thing happened at Paypal, and Paypal became hugely successful shortly afterward.

Re:The ShapeShift Hack by btilly on Monday April 25, 2016 @05:05PM (#11567354)
Yeah, I did miss that insinuation.

The CEO has already made enough on previous companies that I find that one a stretch.

Re:The ShapeShift Hack by bnb on Tuesday April 26, 2016 @09:22AM (#11571588)
Someone who has made a lot of money using one-off tactics to make a lot more money? Why would they do that!
Re:The ShapeShift Hack by clarkmoody on Monday April 25, 2016 @05:50PM (#11567659)
This would be wildly surprising and very hard to believe for those in the bitcoin space who know Erik.
Re:The ShapeShift Hack by actsasbuffoon on Monday April 25, 2016 @04:19PM (#11567017)
There's another factor. Rovion implicated Bob, which would be a weird thing for Bob to do. What kind of idiot would defend themselves by pointing at themselves and screaming, "I did it!"?

If Rovion is Bob, then Bob suffers from a particularly stunning strain of stupidity.

Either Bob thinks he's playing some kind of crazy 4-dimensional chess, or he's not Rovion.

Re:The ShapeShift Hack by btilly on Monday April 25, 2016 @05:09PM (#11567389)
Well if Bob knows that they know, what does he have to lose by confirming what is abundantly obvious?

I have a 9 year old kid at home who demonstrably both can think that sort of stuff up, and WOULD if he had anything to gain from doing so. (As far as I know, he reserves that kind of behavior for tricking people in online games...)