Re:Apple admits use of child labour in China
by GHFigs on Saturday February 27, 2010 @09:04PM
(#1156243)
adult workers basically had a union action against them to make sure their own jobs were safe
Cite for this? Or a source on the topic in general?
I don't mean to sound incredulous, it's just that you seem to be familiar with the subject.
Re:Apple admits use of child labour in China
by yequalsx on Saturday February 27, 2010 @07:56PM
(#1156147)
Is this a serious request? You want me to cite the basis for me stating that our society became better by outlawing the employment of children in factories and mines? This isn't obvious to you? I am grateful that people with your point of view didn't prevail when the United States confronted this issue.
Re:Apple admits use of child labour in China
by Enra2 on Saturday February 27, 2010 @09:04PM
(#1156242)
The US and the rest of the west experienced unprecedented per capita BNP growth since around the time western countries banned child labour. This is the reason for increased living standards. It would not have mattered much in the long run who prevailed because rich (by the standards of 1850 we pretty much all are) parents don't let their children work full time in factories.
Re:Apple admits use of child labour in China
by yequalsx on Sunday February 28, 2010 @12:28AM
(#1156503)
When I say the U.S. became a better country by outlawing child labor this had nothing to do with economics. We became better in a moral sense. We Americans equate, too often, the concept of better in a money sense. This is a bad trait amongst us. (I'm not saying you have this bad trait.)
Re:Apple admits use of child labour in China
by Dove on Sunday February 28, 2010 @07:45AM
(#1156814)
I am not completely sure we are better off. Being barred from meaningful work is to the moral detriment of precocious kids.
Not that we should let people in general subject themselves to danger they don't understand, and kids might lack judgement about that. And education absolutely shouldn't be blown off. But there's something appealing to me about kids being able to work real jobs if they're willing and capable.
Something like this . . . http://www.bigheadpress.com/eft?page=14
Re:Apple admits use of child labour in China
by yequalsx on Sunday February 28, 2010 @12:12AM
(#1156482)
But it would have mattered to the children who would have worked in the coal mines had they not been prevented from doing so by the government. In the long run you are correct but we should not let this be the reason for inaction.
I think you may be assuming that either A) the children were forced to work or B) the children (and their parents) just did not know what was good for them. Both seem unlikely to me.
Cite for this, please. As far as I know, we outlawed child factory labor purely because children, with their small bodies that could fit into more-easily-constructed mineshafts, dexterous hands that could assemble small parts, and lesser demand for pay, were being preferred for most jobs, and so adult workers basically had a union action against them to make sure their own jobs were safe. This decreased efficiency, took a source of discretionary income away from children who wanted it (these weren't forced workers; they just took jobs to better their life), and artificially lowered the unemployment of adults who couldn't compete with kids.