News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by calgoo on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:20PM (#11557852)
I would prefer a simple app interface with big buttons (on mobile) to do the exact thing i want, than having to use some chat menu system. So when im in an airport somewhere i can click while walking to order a taxi or check my email or similar. Just exchange the AI for a simple column of changeable links / buttons to my most used functions, allowing to have sublists. Then allow me to use a builtin password safe to get the information to me in a simple modal or similar. I dont want 100 apps on my phone for each service, but i also dont want a closed interface to how i access the information. Web pages are ok, but most of the time i can not modify the interface to remove items i dont care about. This causes time consuming tasks such as zooming to be able to click on links or using interfaces that can change to whatever the developer thinks is better for you.

Could we create standards for things such as bank APIs, travel APIs, store APIs etc? I dont like forcing things on people, but if we could get some type of collaboration and create a UI where the user gets to create buttons / menu options to access those services directly? Let the user add only the needed options to a button on the home screen called "bank" for example.

I dont need OAuth or similar (Dont want that stuff close to my bank account) but some standard way to authenticate? Then just request my PIN whenever it needs to access a stored password. Or just request the password with saved username when accessing the request for the first time and then save it in a session etc.

I guess what i want for my phone is a easily programmable interface where I can setup whatever functions to access my information directly and not needing to access any other app. Apps are great, but it does not solve the issues that exists on desktops. How do we organize all these icons? Using menus or using desktops with icons? using lists of some sort? Very few systems have come close to solving this issue and most are probably more experimental then production. I believe the cloud should be APIs instead of HTML and Apps. Mobile interfaces should just be scriptable interfaces with some per-defined tasks and an easy way to download new tasks that others have done. Now, this does sound like apps, but its more specific: Its more like downloading a script from your bank that accesses your account balance. Then another script for your card balance. Then another script for a transfer etc. Then you just say where in the interface you want these buttons / links and done.

Anyway, time to end my long rant about mobile interfaces.

Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by juancampa on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:49PM (#11557915)
What you're describing is exactly what I've been building for a year+. I'll post a Show HN as soon as the MVP is ready. I'm glad to see at least someone interested in such a product.

Your rant was actually a great read.

Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by calgoo on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:56PM (#11557938)
Sound great! looking forward to having a look when it comes out!
Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by clockwerx on Saturday April 23, 2016 @09:55PM (#11558243)
Could we create open standards? Yes. Will businesses? Probably not. A lot of 'apps' for food act as an aggregator, which is the closest I can come to an API. But they are locked into one provider - hell, even getting opening hours, menu and how to pay standardised is hard. These all have standards available. No one uses them enough.

Why not? Technical difficulty - my local pizza shop doesnt care about running a payment processing endpoint, structured data, etc. Its counter to their goals.

What we need is an open source point of sale system that is web first - oscommerce with a desktop UI kind of thing. Then it becomes easy to add in 'publish standard compliant data'

Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday April 23, 2016 @10:20PM (#11558285)
>Will businesses? Probably not.

Sadly no. The current version of mobile and the web relies on claiming consumer spaces and trying to herd users into them so they can be farmed.

It's a top-down control model.

Thinking in terms of bottom-up user value without imposing top-down control is alien to corporate psychology - even though if businesses agreed open low-friction global standards for payment processing and other kinds of interaction, possibly with some kind of profit sharing, they'd likely do better in the medium to long term.

Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by nostrademons on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:39PM (#11557897)
Kinda like IFTTT?

https://ifttt.com/

Re:Bots won't replace apps, only better apps will replace apps by hanniabu on Saturday April 23, 2016 @07:52PM (#11557928)
Not really, he means having a single interface(or app of that helps you imagine better) that allows one to setup and customize an interface/panel of whatever functions they use most from other apps. Now take away the other apps, and all you have are functions/scripts with a custom interface. Basically your own dashboard with shortcuts for the most commonly used features of apps on your phone, but without having those apps on your phone - just the features, provided by API, hidden behind a custom interface.