The key for me about the EFF is they are usually good at providing sources. I am going to take the time to read the linked Memorandum and Order document and form my own opinion:
> https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/20151106-702Mem_Opinion_...
Although, I do tend to agree with the EFF on a fair amount of issues (not always though).
I think this is evidence of a nascent tech community. We are fractured in our approach to some things (e.g. RMS vs others) and this shows in the varied responses by EFF.
I definitely don't agree with everything they have to say about tech and policy but I am glad they exist. They keep pretty good tabs on government and private company policy. Sometimes it feels weird when they criticize some private company for a policy which I feel is not a big deal, but I just register my disagreement and note they're not me ;-)
On the other hand, even when disagreeing with others' conclusions, sometimes I like a bit of advocacy along with reporting, as it helps remind me people care.
Although to be fair, eff articles do get called out a lot on Hacker News as well - the userbase is diverse, any anything of interest will be argued from both sides, sometimes in good faith, sometimes not. But I think that's why biased articles are more likely to be posted than unbiased ones - the bias is what makes it seems interesting.
I realize there's a great many HNers who love to brandish their libertarian badges at every opportunity, but it makes for a really annoying echo chamber, and it creates unnecessary partisan division on issues we could otherwise rationally discuss.
Lowercase-L libertarian means that you care about liberty. I could have said "classical liberal," which would encompass modern libertarians and the Founders alike.
> echo chamber
I'm not getting a strong libertarian vibe from HN on anything except encryption/privacy, which is really ironic.
I want reporting, not advocacy. The better of the mainstream press outlets are balanced to a fault but get the interesting details wrong or leave them out altogether. The fringe outlets target their core audience with lots of spun details and a lack of opposing viewpoint.
EDIT: If anyone can get past "lefty vs righty" and answer my core question I'd really appreciate it. This is a genuine query for information, not a clever way to troll.