News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by partycoder on Friday April 22, 2016 @03:50PM (#11552111)
Western press always mocks eastern countries because of their policies around surveillance and censorship to restrict free speech. They rarely report on what is going on around here.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by capote on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:18PM (#11552289)
They are two different worlds. There's no comparison. In the west, with cases like these, and people like Snowden, we're trying to defend our free speech and privacy by our standards. We're doing alright, but there are some big problems to solve. And yes, the media needs to cover this more.

But comparing this to censorship and related problems in China and Russia (single-party states with control of speech at the policy level) is just silly, for lack of a better word.

Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by bkor on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:37PM (#11552398)
You didn't really address his argument other than to say it is silly?

In China it is very clear what is happening. In e.g. US it is all considered a secret. Everyone in China is aware of the "Great Big Firewall" and all the various laws restricting what you can and can not say.

Someone linked once to an article explaining that knowing of the existence of a monitoring system results in people changing their behaviors. This even though some of them support the system.

Seems easily comparable to me.

Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by partycoder on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:56PM (#11552503)
Well, here the 2 party system is like choosing between Coca Cola and Pepsi. Not very different from what happens with Communist countries.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by capote on Friday April 22, 2016 @11:12PM (#11553969)
I think you have no idea what you're talking about.

Since you bring up "Communist countries," my grandfather lived in Communist Romania. He was beaten to death in jail over the course of two months on charges of possessing foreign currency [0]. My parents grew up with almost no food to eat, most of the time being tracked by the secret police, everywhere, black car following them home, informants at every corner, in every place they visited. A modern "Communist country" is North Korea. You can do some research on your own regarding that.

Yes, modern Russia and China aren't that bad. But comparing their single-party system (in which the party literally controls everything, and on many occasions silences dissent by "disappearing" people (read: killing them) ) with the United States, is in fact, just plain silly. Whoever pointed out that this is a bad way to argue is wrong. It is simply silly. Having the choice in two parties, where mostly anyone can, in theory, run, this is infinitely more free than a single-party state. People can make themselves known, they can speak what they want (look at Bernie), they can come out of nowhere without being carefully monitored and selected by a single party. Having the choice encourages politicians to at least somewhat work with the people's interest at heart, rather than just the interest of the party.

Your Coca Cola and Pepsi comparison is very myopic. If you cannot tell the difference between the two parties, especially at a time like this, you have no place discussing politics in any forum. Quick summary: one party is a center-right party trying increase funding to social services, the other is a far-right conservative party focused on the religious majority and traditional conservative values. There are many more things to them; the differences are tremendous. Read their Wikipedia pages, and those of their candidates.

Stop with these comparisons, guys. I know the state of affairs isn't great here, I know our media isn't focusing on the right things and we have huge problems with the NSA and privacy matters.

But be grateful for what we have, and appreciate that you live in a country where you will not be killed by the government for speaking too loud.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gheorghe_Ursu

Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by jack9 on Sunday April 24, 2016 @02:52AM (#11558843)
> one party is a center-right party trying increase funding to social services, the other is a far-right conservative party focused on the religious majority and traditional conservative values

Stop drinking the soda. Those are the most colorful agendas which often result in 1 or 2 grand policy gestures to point at. In practice, the majority of the time is spent bolstering the businesses of donors. To whit, this is EXACTLY what communist countries produce, once they get the populace under control after a few purges.

Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by hn4Trump on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:24PM (#11552652)
Cool, so would ya mind voting for Trump since he is the same as Hilary anyway? ok, thx!
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by tracker1 on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:58PM (#11552818)
I don't know that I see one as concretely worse than the other though. I don't like either of them.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by tobbyb on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:45PM (#11552459)
This is like 2 prisoners arguing about their level of freedom.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by badmadrad on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:52PM (#11552485)
I would argue that true freedom doesn't exist nor has it ever existed in the purest sense so what are we all arguing for?
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by advantark on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:13PM (#11552588)
We're arguing for our right to due process. Something that is thrown away when secret courts make such big decisions.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by skylan_q on Friday April 22, 2016 @05:06PM (#11552555)
Why go to the other side of the world? What about Canada, where we have hate speech laws and the CHRC?
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by ThomPete on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:34PM (#11552380)
I think the point was more that maybe we should spend less time on others and more time on ourselves.
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by takeda on Friday April 22, 2016 @11:06PM (#11553947)
> But comparing this to censorship and related problems in China and Russia (single-party states with control of speech at the policy level) is just silly, for lack of a better word.

I'm not so sure, I remember when Poland was under Russian control (before 1989). At least when you were making a phone call they had courtesy to say that your call is monitored.

Today the technology advanced so much that not only someone can listen your conversation, but also all of your conversation could be recorded and stored for years. Even if you don't care about that. Such information could be used to blackmail people in public offices allowing to control legislative and judicial branches. This itself endangers democracy.

Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by tumblen on Friday April 22, 2016 @04:39PM (#11552413)
But which direction are we moving in?
Re:Secret Court Takes Another Bite Out of the Fourth Amendment by rconti on Friday April 22, 2016 @06:46PM (#11553064)
Are you sure? Because it seems like they report on what is going on around here quite frequently.