I can't imagine that an iPhone with a battery door would cost more than pennies more to manufacture. iPhones are fragile, and have always been; if they can charge you $79 for a new battery, they can charge you $79 to fix the battery door. Smaller/lighter/thinner? You're talking a razor-thin space savings that adds up to a major inconvenience for users. Users have been operating battery doors for a very long time without electrocuting themselves or losing fingers. They're about as dangerous as an SD slot.
> I'm sure the internal discussions that led non-user-replaceable batteries was more nuanced than "let's milk those suckers for all they're worth".
I'm sure Snidely Whiplash doesn't work there. That a decision both so profitable and user-hostile was made is neither an incidental part of a general striving for perfection, nor undiscussed.
It's really challenging to cram that much stuff into a constrained enclosure, and all of the layers add up. As I understand, a removable battery takes up a lot of area, because you need clearance below it and space for the mechanical fasteners. It also breaks up the pristine surfaces that are a big part of Apple's design language. The individual industrial design, product design, electrical, and RF design/antenna engineers responsible for each part aren't thinking about sales in two years. They want to make their piece as good as they can and hit the schedule.
- Easier/cheaper manufacturing process.
- Increased structural stability.
- Make the device smaller/thinner/lighter.
- Apple is concerned that end users will screw something up, so they want their service staff to handle battery replacement.
I'm sure the internal discussions that led non-user-replaceable batteries was more nuanced than "let's milk those suckers for all they're worth".