Ultimately, you have to be happy that spenders overlay for stuff, and the interest gains on savings are better than the tax hit, and day-to-day financial security makes you feel good and finances better opportunities -- like you can afford to move for a job or whatever.
For those of you who prefer the whistling-past-the-graveyard approach, Christopher Buckley's book 'Boomsday' is hilarious.
Anyone care to share how they are protecting their savings against this increasingly likely prospect?
But the tipping point comes when you have to take too much from present workers for past obligations, and some of them say, "wait, screw this, I'll just take my labor somewhere else", which means they have to tax a bigger incentives, which scares off more workers, and spirals out that way.
Relatedly, I have grave reservations about prodding the entire economy to have a huge nest egg in 401k-eligible investments, which can distort the voting base into favoring government interventions that favor the largest companies over smaller ones that don't get publicly listed, changing the playing field.
Yes, definitely.
In addition to all the other diversification advice you can read everywhere, you need to have three pots of savings:
1) pre-tax retirement savings such as traditional 401(k) or traditional IRA
2) post-tax retirement savings such as Roth 401(k) or Roth IRA
3) normal cash and investments, outside of any sort of retirement scheme
Being diversified in that fashion will give you more flexibility to react appropriately to any changes in the tax laws.
And, if you can swing it, you also want some assets that aren't readily visible to the tax man. In decades past, that meant something like a Swiss bank account. Now, perhaps, it might mean something like gold coins.
And there are even more exotic ways to "shelter" your assets. My father, who was displaced by WWII, stressed the value of a good education in a useful field. A malevolent government could confiscate your house and your money, but it couldn't take away what was inside your head.
Politically, it will be a slam-dunk to tax the crap out of money coming out of Roth IRAs in the future.
The most active voters are the older groups, and as people like the author reach their elder years with nothing to retire on, they presumably vote in their own best interest.
As it stands now, there are ~$4 trillion dollars[1] in 401k savings. It is currently not being taxed, with the assumption that it will grow during a person's working years, and be taxed when it is withdrawn, as income tax.
However, as people like the author reach a certain age, I am fairly convinced that there will be a significant tax on retirement savings from the responsible folks to pay for those who didn't save appropriately. Politically it's fairly straightforward: we have millionaires who can "afford" to help pay for the less fortunate! This ends up hurting the people who saved so that they could properly afford to send their kids to schools, to be able to go on vacations in their retirement, etc.
As much as the story has been "max out your 401k!", I'm fairly convinced that it's going to end up being a worse deal than people count on. I don't really have a solution other than to "diversify investments", but stories like this do terrify me. I plan for retirement and try to be responsible about how I live my life so that when I choose to retire, I'll be able to enjoy it and spend time with kids/grandkids or golfing/traveling/whatever.
[1] https://www.ici.org/policy/retirement/plan/401k/faqs_401k