You're both saying the same thing.
As for the good people vs. bad people argument, it should be noted that the good people have a harder job than the bad people. For the bad people to do their job, they only have to find one exploit, whereas the good people have to find most/all of them to have made the system secure. That's why employing people to work on security matters (whether through a bug bounty program or through direct employment), a company that values security shouldn't rely on unpaid volunteers alone.
This isn't about trusting that the company isn't try to dupe you. It's about trusting that the company can implement security properly, and that enough "good" people will find security flaws before the "bad" guys do.