News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GoBGP: BGP Implemented in Go by tptacek on Monday April 18, 2016 @02:04PM (#11521901)
I didn't say it was. But then: I don't trust that Cisco C code at all. Do you?
Re:GoBGP: BGP Implemented in Go by kbenson on Monday April 18, 2016 @02:42PM (#11522180)
In the decade I worked at an (smaller, regional) ISP, there were a number of times that I know of that Cisco provided a custom firmware to us get around a bug we found that prevented regular configuraitons from working as expected. Considering the scale of Cisco, and that we were small enough at the time to need less than five people in network operations, I find that terrifying. They weren't security issues, but it does point towards their code base being too complex for them to adequately manage.
Re:GoBGP: BGP Implemented in Go by sre_ops on Monday April 18, 2016 @03:11PM (#11522378)
Yes. It currently runs over 70% of global internet and considering all kinds of error conditions that show up on the global internet the code is extremely stable.
Re:GoBGP: BGP Implemented in Go by tptacek on Monday April 18, 2016 @08:47PM (#11524164)
Sendmail used to run on something like 90% of the global Internet. And mail in the 1990s pretty much did work, pretty reliably. Would you have banked your site's security on the quality of Sendmail 8.6.12's code?
Re:GoBGP: BGP Implemented in Go by nickpsecurity on Monday April 18, 2016 @09:13PM (#11524271)
Slam dunk on that comment! Such systems, due to lots of debugging, can work reliably in a narrow set of use cases where specific features have massive use. Then there's the uncommon, usage scenarios and features that get much less debugging. Then there's all the patches they keep distributing to fix... "things."

And then the fact that safe, reliable code is only first step toward secure code where an intelligence, malicious person is targeting it. Totally different ballpark that neither Sendmail nor Cisco handled so well. Small shops like Sentinel and Secure64 did way better with a tiny fraction of the money. So, it has to be intentional for the extra profit at customers' expense.

Re:GoBGP: BGP Implemented in Go by Intermernet on Monday April 18, 2016 @09:06PM (#11524240)
Extremely stable, but not extremely secure. This could be said for many companies, and Cisco shouldn't really be singled out here, but I think this is part of tptacek's overall point. The world should move away from huge C code-bases for critical infrastructure and adopt "safer" languages (Personally I love Go, but Rust may be a better option for high-speed packet routing).