News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death in the Atlantic: The Last Four Minutes of Air Franc... by jrockway on Thursday February 25, 2010 @09:08PM (#1152170)
But keep in mind what the physical FBW controls on the Airbus are like -- it's a gaming joystick that you control with your left hand (if you are the captain). I am shocked that A380s can land in crosswinds at all.

There is also no non-synthetic force-feedback; if the computers don't think there is force, you don't feel any force. (Actually, I'm not sure there is any feedback on the Airbus. But I have only seen video demonstrations of the FBW system.) On mechanical or hydraulic flight controls, you can feel the control surfaces not moving because ... you can't move them. (I believed this helped the pilots of Alaska Airlines 261 realize what was happening. Everyone died anyway, but at least the pilots knew what was wrong...)

I assume if the software totally fails, the plane is simply uncontrollable. I can't believe it would be designed that way, but I can't imagine how you are going to move the control surfaces either. (The software doesn't even have to fail; it could just ignore your input. I believe that some inputs are ignored in normal operation anyway, so this could just be a simple bug.)

Anyway, FBW scares me... but I am not a pilot or airplane designer.

There are no comments on this comment yet.