No, the nationalized oil wells are still owned by the Venezuelan people. What they ran out of is the era of high oil prices. Most of their economy hinges on oil prices. They're a lot like Detroit in that a single industry overdetermines their outcome.
On the plus side, Venezuela is nothing like Detroit in that there is no private capital flight leading a rush for the exits taking that industry with them.
Detroit: now THERE'S a case of running away with other people's money. And livelihoods. And clean water.
Of course, Bloomberg won't be spending a lot of time chest-beating about that.
The nationalization destroyed foreign investment, talent fled the country, and cronyism put incompetent people in charge of factories and industries they didn't understand.
It's dishonest to pretend this is only due to oil prices.
The former is corporate-speak annual-report, think-tank framing, the latter is paternalistic, cigars-on-the-golf-course framing, but both are identical messages: colonialist horseshit used -- for centuries now -- to justify looting and extraction from populations.
Adults should be able to see through this stuff by now.
"public ownership is ineffective"
how does this have anything to do with colonialism? I think that public ownership is almost always inefficient compared to an effective market. I believe it is true in the first world, I believe it is true in the third world. don't try to contort it into racism.
Oh, don't worry about me. Worry instead about the dumb, ahistorical position you've staked out here.
1) You claimed VZ's oil industry was "incompetent" and that its "talent fled" leading to the people of VZ being "unable to understand" their industry. These were your exact words. But when I correctly summed up your argument with the paraphrase "they're too dumb," all of a sudden you back away from your own argument, as if it had shat itself.
That cheesy evasion on your part inclines adults to be MORE suspicious of your argument, not less.
2) Literally every argument for colonial extraction of resources from indigenous populations has, for centuries of history now, been made in exactly the manner you have made it: the locals aren't advanced enough to realize the value from their resources. Therefore we HAVE to mine the gold, drill the oil, harvest the fruit, etc. Thus, foreign "investment" is necessary.
This is capitalism at its most disgusting: dressed up in frilly underwear with "altruism" stitched across its ass. The argument is the definition of self-serving, and, as I've said, adults should be able to see through it by now. I can tell you the indigenous peoples of Iran, Chile, Nigeria, Canada, the US, Australia, Venezuala, ad infinitum, already do.
GP's words.
> leading to the people of VZ being "unable to understand" their industry
Your words.
Those do not mean the same thing.
GP is referring to the cronies in charge when they say "people". Not the people of Venezuela.
Distinction without difference fallacy.
I'm sure that is your wish, but we can all read.
Yeah, I'd change the subject too if I had nothing.
Edit in case it wasn't clear: because that's the mechanism by which other people's money was brought into the system.
This demonstrate a serious road block in addressing the rise of (authoritarian) socialist policies in developing economies is the fact that they usually start from honest good intentions. Such as diminishing class-systems and inequality. But like many attempts at centrally planning massive human activity, it's built on faulty assumptions that the system is sustainable in the long run.
Ultimately resulting in a slowly dwindling ponzi scheme. Only made worse when it happens in a petro-state like Venezuela where the scheme can last long enough with the appearance of success to persuade other nearby countries to buy into the illusion.
Since you asked, I believe in compensating ability via markets while providing basic income to all parties. Instead of trying to apply some kind of centralized reverse meritocracy to social support systems, or worse, via tax rebates and business development programs.