"The lack of those fundamentals has been the main trouble with
advertising of the past. Each worker was a law unto himself. All
previous knowledge, all progress in the line, was a closed book to
him. It was like a man trying to build a modern locomotive without
first ascertaining what others had done. It was like a Columbus
starting out to find an undiscovered land.
Men were guided by whims and fancies - vagrant, changing
breezes. They rarely arrived at their port. When they did, quite by
accident, it was by a long roundabout course. " - Claude C. Hopkins, Scientific Advertising
That was published in 1923 and still rings true.I think the crux of the issue is that some areas within an organization are judged by the metrics equivalent of divination.
That looseness and lack of maturity allows a lot of cruft to accumulate, and trends to take hold in the larger ecosystem. Think of how little room there is for trends in physics, commission based salesmanship or C compilers. Then compare that with software development methodology, marketing and whatever the hot new .js is up to. And with the low barriers to calling yourself a "marketer", you end up with n-th derivatives of things that were cargo-cult to begin with.
I wont mention any names but I saw a mistake with canonical tags cost a major UK company 1/2 a mill in less than a week.
edit: the GP didn't specify any units though. He could have been talking about visitors or micromorts, not pounds or dollars.
On the other hand: "The four P's" is a man-made concept, too. So is the entire framework the author shows off. So why is "inbound marketing" a sham while "the four P's" is gospel? That whole part is a rant about terminology more than anything else.
There needs to be more skepticism and calling-out-BS within marketing, but that doesn't mean rejecting every new idea because it doesn't fit a decades-old mold. Rejecting everything is just as intellectually lazy as accepting everything.
To give an example: I'm an engineer-turned-marketer and now consult tech companies. I never received a "traditional" marketing education so I'd get schooled on theory by a first-year marketing student, but I can automate marketing operations, increase conversion rates, deploy code, turn more trial users into customers, and so on. Between those things and "The Four P's," which do you think matters more to a startup?
Theory is useful but dismissing an entire industry (tech) because they don't subscribe to an old theory or choose to use new terminology is ignorant.