> let's not forget Gordon Brown
Oh he gets no free pass on pensions - he raided them for billions.
My personal pension has performed disastrously from 2 bad years it'll probably never recover properly from. There went my early retirement thoughts. My parent's generation retirement options look pretty good.
I empathise with you on the personal pension - but that's the reality of risk/reward investments. I'd have thought a lot of the bad performance should have recovered based on current markets? Depending on your age the solution is usually to: -Contribute more -Risk on (aiming for higher rewards) -Work longer.
I think it's really really important to recognise that early retirement probably means finishing work ~65 years old if you want a comparable "lifetime in retirement" to earlier generations who retired at 55. One simply cannot expect to spend 25 years in full retirement after only working 25 years. I think as a society we've got to make some huge adjustments in expectations, because we're stuck in a mindset from 70 years ago that isn't really viable. Personally I expect to aim to retire "early" into a different role that is less stressful and in the countryside - but I don't intend to stop working until much later.
[1] I haven't seen updated numbers in a few years, maybe it's better now..
This isn't even slightly true - you can look at a company such as BA which is now a pension deficit with an airline attached - the liabilities drastically outsize the company turnover. That means Interest Rate changes and Mortality expectation changes cause changes in funding requirements which are completely un-sustainable.
The changes to pension funds under Thatcher (and let's not forget Gordon Brown, too, wanted a piece of that money and was willing to screw people over to get it) definitely had a negative impact - but final/average salary defined benefits pensions are by design unsustainable because they never considered the current economic environment as a possibility.
Back when interest rates were 10%+ and most people died before taking 10 years of pension, they seemed like a good idea.