News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by jdminhbg on Thursday February 25, 2010 @01:24PM (#1151200)
Beyond the hand-waving about "big industry" and "corporate agendas," there's not much here beyond the willingness to endorse authoritarianism in the service of encouraging the style of internet sharing the author prefers.

More serious is the apparent blitheness with which the author assumes that only big companies will be affected by speech regulations. On the contrary, it's normally small operators who are intimidated into shutting down by speech regulations like DMCA or the late, unlamented COPA. The Google in Italy case is newsworthy precisely because the government there bullied an entity with the resources to try to fight back.

Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by jchrisa on Thursday February 25, 2010 @02:08PM (#1151311)
So you'd rather be protected by the feudal lord (Google) than stand on your own? Make no mistake that's what you're saying.
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by archgoon on Thursday February 25, 2010 @03:45PM (#1151535)
I don't think that I would describe Google as a feudal lord, what with it not having the power to really do anything to me except deny me it's services. I have sworn no vows of fealty that force me to wage war on their behalf, with execution for dereliction of said vows. Even if I were an employee of theirs, I would still be allowed to quit.

Now, am I happy to let Google fight legal battles that I agree with that I can't fight on my own, due to lack of resources and standing? Yes.

Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by jdminhbg on Thursday February 25, 2010 @02:21PM (#1151349)
No, I'm saying it's highly unlikely that the "king" is going to shut down the "feudal lord" and then let me, the "peasant," do whatever I want to.
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by jchrisa on Thursday February 25, 2010 @02:26PM (#1151361)
You shouldn't be able to do whatever you want. Unless you only want to do good things. Law isn't perfect but it is meant to be applied impartially.
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by Semiapies on Thursday February 25, 2010 @08:37PM (#1152130)
What about the things that aren't "good", but aren't harmful to anyone - things like lolcats and blog posts about how the whole web should be running out of home servers? Shouldn't people be able to do those?
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by kelnos on Friday February 26, 2010 @02:24AM (#1152670)
We're not talking about Italy's hatred of a lolcats video. We're talking about a video of 3 kids taunting an autistic kid. If someone put that video on their home server and showed it to the world, they'd (hopefully) be just as liable as if they put it on YouTube.

If Italy is fine with lolcats on YT, presumably they'd be fine with lolcats on my home server.

Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by Semiapies on Friday February 26, 2010 @01:05PM (#1153692)
Your reply isn't actually to what I said, but I'll respond to you:

The video is not the harm; the original taunting is. If it's a manner of protecting a minor, we can talk about pulling the video down.

If the kids were selling the video and making money off it, we can talk about prosecuting them.

Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by kelnos on Saturday March 20, 2010 @05:47AM (#1206257)
Why is making money off of something the threshold for prosecution? Is the video (or the act itself) somehow less harmful to someone when it isn't commercially viable?
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by janl on Friday February 26, 2010 @02:43AM (#1152697)
Your freedom to swing your arms ends in front of my nose.
Re:Imagine There's No YouTube by Semiapies on Friday February 26, 2010 @01:06PM (#1153696)
As a question, that would be a correct paraphrase of what I just asked.