News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gmail Retires 5 and Graduates 6 Labs Features by davidw on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:28AM (#1150454)
Gmail is really interesting. I'm a big free-software fan - I really dislike running non-free stuff on my own computer. Not so much for RMS reasons, but just because I like the freedom to hack on stuff as I see fit, and partly just to support open source (it has given me so much over the years). I've never had that hangup about online services though, even though logically they're not really that different. And indeed, I switched to Gmail several years ago because their anti-spam was (and still is, I think) way better than what I was able to cobble together with Linux.

However, every now and then I'm reminded that in giving up some freedom, you pay a price. I would love to try and hack in a feature to Gmail that makes it permanently associate certain From email adddresses with people. For instance, if I write someone and set the From to @dedasys.com, I want future email with that person to always use that address. If I use the @apache.org address, then that should be used in the future, unless I change it. I can't implement this, though, as far as I know.

Re:Gmail Retires 5 and Graduates 6 Labs Features by sliverstorm on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:36AM (#1150464)
> I can't implement this, though, as far as I know.

I understand your point, and I know you aren't arguing against Google, but... supposing you were able to... would you? I'd bet at least 999 out of 1,000 users of any given open client- Thunderbird for example- would not invest the effort, or could not due to lack of skill. And this is with Thunderbird- GMail's penetration into markets with unskilled non hacker types is drastically greater.

Ironically, I guess you could say my argument is that like the features they are phasing out- not enough people would truly use it!

If you really wanted to, there might be that kind of ability in gears. Perhaps low level, or perhaps just through manipulating the UI- a bit of a macro.

Re:Gmail Retires 5 and Graduates 6 Labs Features by davidw on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:40AM (#1150470)
Yes, it's likely I would if it weren't too difficult.

I implemented the "Oops, do you want to send an attachment" feature in mutt years ago, and sent in the patch, which, sadly, was not accepted.

Most people don't hack on stuff - no argument there. But some of us do, and I think that we occasionally make the world a better place.

Re:Gmail Retires 5 and Graduates 6 Labs Features by sliverstorm on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:42AM (#1150471)
The more power to ya then :)

No disagreement here. hackers have made my world a much better place many times.