News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let’s draw Feynman diagrams! by ewjordan on Thursday February 25, 2010 @03:41AM (#1150302)
I'm not really sure why anyone would want to bother drawing Feynman diagrams if they didn't need to calculate the amplitudes associated with them. There are very few physical effects that can be explained through Feynman diagrams without understanding a lot more than this article offers about the math that these diagrams involve.

Typically Feynman diagrams are offered as a way to simplify the accounting involved in doing quantum field theory calculations. To treat them as a view of what is "really happening" is a bit misleading, especially to an audience that is not intimately familiar with the oddities of quantum mechanics. I'm not saying everyone needs to understand path integrals to "get" the basics of QFT, but it would be a real mistake to think that you could understand anything nontrivial about the theory by looking at mere Feynman diagrams - QFT's magic is in how you calculate the amplitudes from diagrams, not in the construction of the diagrams themselves.

And at the very least, some justification for ignoring the higher level Feynman diagrams needs to be offered, especially since in certain quantum field theories we can't pull the same kind of crap that we can get away with in QED, and it doesn't make any sense to ignore the more complicated diagrams.

Re:Let’s draw Feynman diagrams! by randallsquared on Thursday February 25, 2010 @07:52AM (#1150543)
I can't tell if you're joking, but in case you aren't:

To treat them as a view of what is "really happening" is a bit misleading, especially to an audience that is not intimately familiar with the oddities of quantum mechanics.

There is no simplified layman's view of any complex subject which is not at least a bit misleading.

And at the very least, some justification for ignoring the higher level Feynman diagrams needs to be offered

Audience. The post starts out by mentioning that he's talking only about stuff that could be done by school children, or the whole family. It's a bit tongue-in-cheek, but I didn't get the impression that he was completely unserious about that.

Re:Let’s draw Feynman diagrams! by donaq on Thursday February 25, 2010 @04:48AM (#1150359)
Can't you let us mere mortals catch our glimpse of the magical forces the demigods of physics deal with in peace!