Re:A Healthy Hatred of OOP, or the principles of my message-...
by kazagistar on Saturday April 23, 2016 @02:20PM
(#11556677)
There is a difference between definition and assumption. An assumption says that something about the world is true. A definition just says what meaning you will intend by a word in the current scope.
When you define OOP, you aren't saying anything about the real world, just stuff about the words you will be using within the current context.
If the author is using a wrong definition as a starting point, the rest of the argument is largely pointless...or must be explicitly marked as a hypothetical/counterfactual.
"I define the earth as being an infinite flat plane, from this it follows [for the real world] that..."
Well, no, the earth is not an infinite plane, even if it kinda looks that way, was long believed to be that (maybe minus the infinite) and apparently there still are people who believe that.