News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man accidentally 'deletes his entire company' with one li... by xg15 on Thursday April 14, 2016 @06:41PM (#11500850)
I'm glad we have the same opinion then - as I said, it's not very useful to reason about "perfect safety".

It's certainly possible to make a product "safer" then necessary and hinder utility (though I think "safety" is the wrong concept to look at here - see below) but if the common opinion of your product from tech-illiterate people is "complicated and scary", I think you can be pretty sure that you are still a long way away from that point.

In fact, some versions of rm do add additional protection against root deletions, e.g. the --no-preserve-root flag. What utility did that flag destroy?

I believe if you really want to make people more tech-literate (which today's apps are doing a horrible job of, I agree), you have to give them a honest and consistent view of their system, yes. But you also have to design the system such that they can learn and experiment as safely as possible and can quickly deduce what a certain action would do before they do it.

Cryptic commands, which are only understandable after extensive study of documentation, and which oh by the way become deadly in very specific circumstances don't help at all here.

Re:Man accidentally 'deletes his entire company' with one li... by nickpsecurity on Thursday April 14, 2016 @08:22PM (#11501250)
"Cryptic commands, which are only understandable after extensive study of documentation, and which oh by the way become deadly in very specific circumstances don't help at all here."

Exactly. That's another problem that was repeatedly mentioned in UNIX Hater's Handbook. It still exists. Fortunately, there's distro's improving on aspects of organization, configuration, command shells, and so on. I'm particularly impressed with NixOS doing simple things that should've been done a long time ago.