News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:51AM (#11496633)
In this case, the problem wasn't so much that Trib Corp had poor security (they probably do though), but rather that an insider exfiltrated credentials to one of their servers to an IRC channel. There are a few companies in our industry where that attack wouldn't be devastating, because of very carefully designed security programs. But there are not many of those companies. Most companies you've heard of are just as vulnerable as Trib Corp was.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by matt_wulfeck on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:17AM (#11496900)
But charging them with hacking? And putting them in prison for 2 years?
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:18AM (#11496903)
There's no such charge as "hacking".
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by matt_wulfeck on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:42AM (#11497090)
Of course. We're able to make the distinction of being hacked versus someone crawling through an open window. If only jurors could be expected to do the same.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:44AM (#11497109)
What distinction is it that you're trying to make? Crawling into a building through an open window is no less of a crime than picking the locks. In fact: it's exactly the same crime.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by possibility on Thursday April 14, 2016 @06:40PM (#11500849)
Picking the locks is breaking and entering, going through an open window is illegal trespass, assuming you don't have to move any parts of the window. At least where I live. It depends on whether or not you have to use even the slightest amount of force to gain access. It also depends on your intent to commit a crime inside. If I'm looking for you because I've found your toddler wandering around outside and I open an unlocked door to call out your name, it isn't a crime. I'm not sure what happens if I pick a locked door in that situation, getting pretty contrived now. But let's say I heard your kid crying inside that you'd abandoned, it wouldn't be a crime to pick the lock and rescue him/her.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @06:57PM (#11500923)
No, I don't think this is at all correct. Going through a window is breaking and entering.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by possibility on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:04PM (#11500952)
Well, I didn't know, so I looked it up before posting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burglary

> Although rarely listed as an element, the common law required that "entry occur as a consequence of the breaking".[7] For example, if a wrongdoer partially opens a window with a pry bar—but then notices an open door, which he uses to enter the dwelling, there is no burglary under common law.

There are more results if you search for "breaking and entering", it was all pretty consistent.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:07PM (#11500971)
See for instance Massachusetts model jury instructions, which are explicit that opening an unlocked door constitutes "breaking".
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by possibility on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:13PM (#11500991)
Yes, but that's using force to open the door, which was in my original claim about no force on an open window.

Reading that WP article again, turns out I was just considering the common law part. It later says:

> The common law definition has been expanded in most jurisdictions, such that the building need not be a dwelling or even a building in the conventional sense, physical breaking is not necessary, the entry does not need to occur at night, and the intent may be to commit any felony or theft.

So I'll give it to you for "physical breaking is not necessary", even though I don't actually know about the jurisdiction in question. (I didn't rtfa.)

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:15PM (#11500997)
What's your point, though? If opening an unlocked door is B&E, what does the lockpicking analogy teach us?
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by possibility on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:26PM (#11501048)
Oh, I was literally just arguing the other side about going through an open window because I didn't know for sure if it was burglary. (Common law says no, but that's probably updated, but maybe not in some places, but I didn't check them all.)

I don't see how you could access a computer without using "force", any input from a human constitutes force in my opinion. So no disagreement as far as the actual crime is concerned, I'm just nitpicking for fun...

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by possibility on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:51PM (#11501137)
On reflection, perhaps this pointless diversion yields the following maxim:

  You can walk into a house through an open door,
  but you can't walk into a computer.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:06PM (#11501414)
You can totally walk into a computer. I've done it. Hurts.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by possibility on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:13PM (#11501625)
The only machine around here that I could totally walk into is an S/390, but oddly enough I don't have the key to its bedroom.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by baldfat on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:50AM (#11497161)
Those keys were those of an ex-employee. When you let a person go or they leave the company those credentials should have been changed.
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by danielweber on Thursday April 14, 2016 @02:39PM (#11499311)
They should have. He also should not have given out the password.

A failure to change the locks does not mean you have created an attractive nuisance to former employees.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2016 @03:58PM (#11499861)
Attractive nuance is supposed to apply to children.

However, failure to collect keys get's into murky situations.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @04:39PM (#11500156)
Can you be more specific about the murky situation we're talking about here? I moved offices from Oak Park back into Chicago a few months back. The landlord never collected the key. My old office was rented out (I can see from the window). Can I go look around inside it?
Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2016 @04:46PM (#11500208)
It's not that you have the right to go back. Rather, by failing to change the locks they might have some liability if you did go back.

If a lessor or landlord in Illinois does not change or rekey the unit's lock before the day the new tenant or lessee takes possession, and a THEFT occurs at that dwelling unit that is attributable to the lessor's failure to change or rekey the lock, the landlord is liable for any damages from the theft that occurs as a result of the lessor's failure to comply with the law http://www.securitydepositlaw.com/blog/chicago-tenants-right...

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @05:04PM (#11500334)
No, that's actually not true of commercial leases in Chicago. It's true of residential leases because residential landlords have a whole bunch of very specific issues about key changes.

But stipulate that it was true. What bearing does that have on this case? If I go into that office and steal $5000 worth of computer equipment, am I not liable for felony grand theft because the landlord has civil liability to the tenant?

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2016 @05:44PM (#11500576)
Liability can be shared and a tenant may greatly prefer going after an ex. landlord vs. some random person.

Granted, this does not apply in your case, but Chicago does have mixed use Residential/Commercial leases which is covered.

Now suppose a tenant goes back to retrieve their property the day after there lease ends. Which under some situations they are allowed to do. Key works, the enter building...

IANAL, but would suggest this is a situation the owner would like to avoid.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @06:22PM (#11500786)
Your concern here is over moral hazard. You're saying, the law makes landlords liable for theft so that they'll do their duty to secure their building. I'm not arguing this point; moral hazard makes a lot of sense. If you want to argue that Trib Corp should have some negligence liability here, fine.

But there is no sense in which that kind of liability mitigates the criminal actions of others. If I go into a building for which the landlord is liable for theft, and I steal $5000 worth of crap (or cause $5000 worth of damage), I'm going to be prosecuted for that if I'm caught, no matter the landlord's liability. Criminal liability isn't shared due to negligence, and when criminal liability is shared (among accomplices and co-conspirators), it's not divided up among the parties --- because that would be silly.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2016 @07:26PM (#11501050)
Morale hazard does play into what they can clam as damages. If reverting the defacement using there CMS system costs 500$ and results in 2,000 in lost profit NP. If it takes someone a few hours to verify that was the only change, NP.

But, they can't claim time related to revoking his permissions because they should have done that in the first place. Ditto for performing a security audit ect.

This is a normal user using there CMS system, not an admin or developer messing with things.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Thursday April 14, 2016 @09:10PM (#11501429)
I'm only going on here because I'm worried I've been unclear about the nature of the damage here.

If you're objecting to the idea that, having caused a breach, the convicted attacker is now on the hook for securing the application they broke, so that the attack they used is no longer viable, I agree. That is in no way fair.

But that's not what's happening.

Instead, having been breached, and only because they've been breached, the victim is now in a position of needing to assess the extent of the damage done. They can't guess --- at least, not if they're a major corporation --- because continuing to operate when you have reason to believe you've been systemically compromised is unethical and dangerous.

That's the difference between a DF/IR audit and a security audit. A security audit tries to find all your vulnerabilities. A DFIR audit tries to scope the compromise and retain evidence. Of the two, the DFIR audit has a narrower scope and more specific purpose.

But, weirdly, it's also more expensive. There are more application security consultants than there are DFIR auditors, and DFIR auditors are often selected by insurance companies, not by the market.

At any rate: the costs we're talking about Keys having incurred are not a bonanza of free assessment work Trib gets to bill to Keys.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by Retric on Thursday April 14, 2016 @10:03PM (#11501591)
Someone logged into the CMS system using an active account and changed something in the CMS system. Are they required to do an audit of anything outside the CMS system, no.

I accept that you feel an external audit is required. But, is it a reasonable expense directly incurred, no.

PS: As a parting piece of evidence. Was $10,206 to $13,147 likely to include DFIR audit and all other costs? No.

Re:Former Reuters Journalist Matthew Keys Sentenced to Two Y... by tptacek on Friday April 15, 2016 @11:48AM (#11505235)
What do you think they spent $13,000 on?