Re:Why Y Combinator’s Hacker News Is Flawed
by viraptor on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @04:42PM
(#1149256)
5 is also a very nice feature that allows never-ending fights known from forums to die. There's no way to bring back some old rant by replying "You're wrong!". Unfortunately that happens on mailing lists and forums quite a lot.
Otherwise I can imagine the front page would consist of "git vs hg", "dvorak vs qwerty", "python vs ruby", "nosql vs rdbms", "lisp vs everything", ...
Inevitable for a news site.
2. The Point system sets the wrong incentives Most people seem to be in it for the points.
This could happen, but I haven't seen many signs of it. Personally, I try to avoid making comments that might get a negative karma score, but I don't much care how high a positive score I get. IMO The points system works well; I especially like the way that negative karma posts are 'named and shamed'.
3. There is no way to search
This is a reasonable point.
4. Using HN as a discussion forum doesn’t work.
Ask and Tell HN threads appear frequently, so this doesn't seem to be a problem. And I find the discussions on HN to be excellent.
5. There is no way to revive old discussions
IMO, this is a good thing for HN. It prevents it turning into a traditional web forum - not that web forums are a bad thing, they just tend to be more insular, and there's more of a split between regulars and newcomers.