News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by maxklein on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:15PM (#1148957)
That's pretty cool. So all I need to do is to get a friend of mine to register as an Angel, then give him 100k I've got my Visa. A lot of people can raise 100k - this seems like it would cause a lot of immigration to happen.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:20PM (#1148982)
You'll be ejected when you can't raise $1MM in revenue or (worse) capital within three years. For a lot of people, maybe that doesn't matter; the bill doesn't set out any practical way to ensure that visa applicants are bona fide.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by icey on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:19PM (#1148977)
They've proposed strict requirements as to who can perform these kinds of investments in order to prevent the kind of loophole you're describing.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:21PM (#1148988)
Those requirements are, in their entirety: that you are an accredited investor, and that you've made 2 $50k equity investments within the last 3 years.
Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by icey on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:24PM (#1148995)
Ha, okay so "strict requirements" is not the right way to describe it.

To do what Max was talking about would only require $200K to get in the door, and the willingness of an accredited investor to commit fraud.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @05:57PM (#1149455)
there are obvious rqmts to qualify that require time and effort in addition to capital, and a track record of investment over at least 3 years and 6 previous companies.

there are obvious penalties which would be incurred if someone intentionally abused this system.

legislation does not prevent all types of abuse, however we have attempted to reasonably make it unlikely that such abuse would not occur without great cost and risk to the perpetrators.

we believe we have done a responsible job in drafting the legislation to avoid this. exact language will depend on how the bill gets negotiated before final vote.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:59PM (#1149605)
So, again, requiring a track record of investment over at east 3 years and 6 companies might (for instance) exclude Warren Buffet, and keeping the requirements loose means that virtually anyone can "sponsor" an "entrepreneur" for very little money and get them 3 years residency in the US.

This just doesn't seem well thought out.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:29AM (#1150086)
seriously dude, do you like to argue for no particular reason?

yes, it's likely not all investors will qualify -- not perfect, but it's reasonable to require some domain experience that can be provably audited. and yes, the investors who do qualify will likely not be completely sketchy and/or likely to commit fraud.

we picked a reasonable bar to get over that straddles both a rqmt of experience and some capital without making it so low that people could abuse it.

investing $300,000 in capital in 6 companies over 3 years does NOT seem like "virtually anyone" for "very little money".

your perspective again seems irrational & extreme.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Thursday February 25, 2010 @12:58AM (#1150118)
My perspective is that the "investor sponsorship" component of this bill is arbitrary, unfair, and will distort the market. I've been pretty consistent about this point throughout the whole "argument".

If you don't want to continue arguing, stop arguing. I don't care what bar you picked for investors, except for the fact that it seems obvious that it's modelled on the tech investor clique. If you got the investor model perfect, I'd still have a problem with conflating investment with viability or value to the economy.

I don't believe for one millisecond that you will concede anything about this bill, which you clearly passionately support. That doesn't bother me at all, for what it's worth.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by davemc500hats on Thursday February 25, 2010 @02:09PM (#1151315)
i'm conceding about as much as you are, except i'm arguing from specific economic goals & benefits. you're arguing about "distortions" that appear to be subjective analysis.

if you want to have a discussion where we have the chance to change each others' minds, then perhaps we should be talking about what parts of investor mentality are in question, and why that isn't better than doing nothing / status quo.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by boucher on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @06:28PM (#1149519)
Is the 2 $50k investment's cumulative? In other words, someone like pg makes a lot of small investments. He is obviously included in the kinds of investors you're trying to select with this bill, but would he meet this requirement?

I think it should say at least 2 investments, and at least $100k in total value of the investments.

Re:Senators Kerry & Lugar Introduce the Startup Visa Act by tptacek on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @03:29PM (#1149005)
It wouldn't be fraud. Reread the bill.