News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fallacy of Gray by ytinas on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:02AM (#1148240)
Great post. For some people science is absolutely a religion. These folks don't know enough to try and falsify the theory they believe but they have no issue trashing people who aren't as convinced.
Re:The Fallacy of Gray by nollidge on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @12:19PM (#1148474)
> people who aren't as convinced

...but who somehow feel that they do know enough to try and falsify a theory?

> for some people science is absolutely a religion

Quoth the OP: If science is a religion, it is the religion that heals the sick and reveals the secrets of the stars. It would make sense to say, "The priests of science can blatantly, publicly, verifiably walk on the Moon as a faith-based miracle, and your priests' faith can't do the same." Are you sure you wish to go there, oh faithist? Perhaps, on further reflection, you would prefer to retract this whole business of "Science is a religion too!"

Re:The Fallacy of Gray by ytinas on Thursday February 25, 2010 @03:10AM (#1150269)
>...but who somehow feel that they do know enough to try and falsify a theory?

You don't have to try to falsify a theory not to believe it. Agnostic is also a valid position (so long as you're not trying to influence others one way or another).

Also, your comment smacks of "you aren't qualified to do anything but agree". Personally, when I hear someone say that one would need years upon years of training before being qualified to even have an opinion I wonder what controls are in place to ensure this qualification process isn't tainting their thinking.

For example, long time programmers of some awful programming language will report that it "works just how I think", but in fact long repetition has programmed them to work and think this way.

>Quoth the OP

Ah, but you've misunderstood me. I'm not saying science is a religion itself, rather that some people put blind faith into it. I've seen plenty of people ridiculing others for not believing in some theory, but when engaged they don't really know anything more than "most people believe this".

I once saw a self-proclaimed Christian ridiculing a non-Christian about some moral issue. When I asked how many times he had read through the bible he admitted he had never read the whole thing. I don't see much difference between this and what I see from some laymen "champions of science" I've encountered.

Re:The Fallacy of Gray by enthalpyx on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @10:46PM (#1149947)
If science gets credit for healing the sick, does it also take the blame for deaths caused by nuclear weapons? Blatant, public, and verifiable. Praise worthy? Not in my book.
Re:The Fallacy of Gray by nollidge on Wednesday February 24, 2010 @11:01PM (#1149972)
> does it also take the blame for deaths caused by nuclear weapons?

In my view, yes, it does, and science needs to learn from that (and countless other mistakes). It's certainly not universally praise-worthy. But it does provide a way for ethical people to reliably improve the human condition.

Re:The Fallacy of Gray by cousin_it on Thursday February 25, 2010 @04:18AM (#1150334)
Who said anything about praise? Yes, my deity can be angry, but my faith is still more true than yours, o Christian.
Re:The Fallacy of Gray by ZeroGravitas on Thursday February 25, 2010 @06:20AM (#1150451)
The same science that lets you heal the sick also tells you how to kill people.