Re:It's time to dispel the myths about nuclear power
by readams on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:16PM
(#11482112)
I'm fascinated by the idea of a "correct fallacy." How could such a thing ever make sense? Are you saying that you use this fallacy to reach a conclusion that you believe correct for other reasons? If so, why not state those other reasons and not use your fallacious reasoning? If not, how could your fallacy be correct?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:It's time to dispel the myths about nuclear power
by Tomte on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @02:28PM
(#11482218)
Me too. :-)
I think that this fallacy is correct in the sense that averting extreme outcomes at the cost of a lower expected outcome is rational when it comes to survival.
I suspect you might be able to explain the existence of those "irrational" behaviours this way, although I haven't searched the literature.
Kind of the opposite of playing the lottery (which I also find rational, despite all the nerds decrying it): There you are giving up expected value, in order to gain variance.
Re:It's time to dispel the myths about nuclear power
by Retra on Tuesday April 12, 2016 @10:30PM
(#11485282)
Something is not rational simply because you think it is. A decision is rational if and only if the invested resources are proportional to the likelihood of success.
A fallacy is a fallacy because it violates this proportionality. Fallacious reasoning can never be rational.