To be clear neither his political or technical views hold merit, his project is an interesting mental exercise, but I doubt many will see any technical merit.
It is so exasperating that so many people who aren't denigrated and targeted by his hateful politics think this is a matter of abstract principle. Somehow, letting my and others' humanity be a matter of political opinion is the mature, apolitical position. Utterly frustrating attitude. It's perfectly fine to be tolerant of Yarvin's views, it is completely unreasonable to ask others to associate with a person who envisions a world where their humanity is forfeit.
If you don't like him, protest him. Disturb him with your words as much as he disturbs you with his.
How about just ignore him.
I'm going to be emphatic, because i am emphatic about this position:
Free speech is a powerful principle because speech has power. Because speech can hurt people, because speech can change the world. If speech did not matter, free speech would not matter.
If speech matters, and speech has power, then its effects must be considered. To do anything less is irrational. The idea that rejecting Yarvin's ideas so emphatically that we would deny him platform would lead to unjust suppression of speech is a fallacy. It is a slippery slope. So many people who strive to be rational individuals and avoid cognitive biases, and yet balk at treating speech for what it is instead of a sacred object that should be worshipped.
By saying Yarvin should be allowed to speak, you are merely saying that protecting his speech is more important than the emotional and professional cost it exacts on the people he targets. And yes, he targets people. Through all his extremely verbose, meandering writings, a clear thread of contempt for certain others' runs.
"The relationship of master and slave is a natural human relationship: that of patron and client." - Curtis Yarvin
You can react to speech the way you want. But you're not taking any moral high ground with your approach when you explicitly deny the impact of speech on others and how they react to it. Association is a form of speech. Petitioning others to stand with you is a form of speech. Protecting Yarvin's speech on the grounds of principle, which is rejecting others' speech out of hand in contradiction of the same principles is inconsistent. All speech has consequences, and there is no neutral advocacy of "free speech" because truly free speech is a realm of conflict and inconsistency.
Inclusivity, egalitarianism, and protecting the views of the minority are in direct contradiction to Curtis Yarvin's thought. So ironically, Curtis Yarvin's mere presence at such a conference would be a direct contradiction of his views. In other words, they're arguing against him by inviting him.
You can't have your cake and eat it too. That is, if you wish to not have your opinions censored you cannot ask for the censorship of other opinions you feel offensive.
I wish bigots and other prejudiced people would spare us, but I value my freedom to speak my mind more than I dislike hearing hateful speech.
If this speaker makes a racial slur he'll likely be removed from the conference. Inside the conference (much like HN) they're free to limit his speech. However, as was mentioned in the article, the conference does not and will not judge speech outside the conference, much like HN does not (to my knowledge) ban users for offensive speech outside HN.
May we assume you'll be moving somewhere without such, rather than trying to tear ours down?
Those people might feel threatened by communist speakers. Do they then have the right to "no platform" those speakers?
But let's take your absurd comparison in good faith: I don't care whether they have the "right" or not, I would oppose retaliation by a state on the merits of the situation. Again I will repeat my exasperation at the idea that one must have a rule that applies to all conflicts of speech uniformly without consideration of context or details of the conflict. No one here wants to grapple with the effects of hate speech on others, they simply want to ignore them, and that is completely irrational. Free speech absolutism is irrational and behaves like dogmatic religion.
Yarvin was disinvited because his political beliefs are threatening (and yes, several people used the word "threatened").
Therefore, communists should also be disinvited if anyone feels threatened.
Yes or no?
I mentioned nothing about "the state", by the way. Clearly Lambaconf is a private organization that can invite (or disinvite) anyone it wants.
I am asking why "feeling threatened" by Yarvin (who, as near as I can figure out --- there's no way I'm going to plow through all that turgid prose) is a political party of one, and who (again, as far as I know) has never actually harmed anyone, is a valid reason for disinvitation while feeling threatened by communists (who most assuredly have actually murdered millions of people) is not.
Do you have an answer to that or not?
I strongly suspect that you do not.
No, I think you're being perfectly clear.
I, and many others, find your disbelief in free speech threatening (frankly, this attitude scares the hell out of me).
That would make it okay for us to prevent you from speaking in public or holding gainful employment? Yes? No? If not, why not?
Streisand effect, people.