News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maps Showing Where FBI Planes Are Watching from Above by rayiner on Sunday April 10, 2016 @05:31PM (#11468282)
Jones was based on the classic idea that when the government does what would be a trespass if a private person did it, then a warrant is required. Observing someone in public is not a trespass, no matter how much you do it.
Re:Maps Showing Where FBI Planes Are Watching from Above by rmxt on Sunday April 10, 2016 @06:24PM (#11468472)
You are correct to say that you can't commit a trespass by observing someone in public. However, trespassing is not an exclusive test as to whether a search is permissible (though it was the applicable rubric for Jones). The Katz test still must be applied, above and beyond the trespassory test. The concurrences in the Jones opinion state "at the very least, “longer term GPS monitoring in investigations of most offenses impinges on expectations of privacy.”

Swap "GPS monitoring" for infrared, EMF, video, audio tracking, whatever those planes are doing, and I think we are at the same level of "impinge(ment) on expectations of privacy."

Is it your opinion that Alito and Sotomayor are barking up the wrong tree? Is this sort of extensive (i.e. multi-modal (visual, EMF, etc.)), and evidently prolonged, monitoring not an impingement on typical expectation of privacy? Sure, this isn't a trespass, but if a private person was doing this to you, wouldn't you want to call the cops? (Oh, wait...)

Re:Maps Showing Where FBI Planes Are Watching from Above by rayiner on Sunday April 10, 2016 @07:04PM (#11468631)
My point is that Jones doesn't really help you: the majority opinion focused on the trespass theory, and did not rely on the consequences of longer-term GPS monitoring.

In my opinion, the whole "expectation of privacy" thing is reading words into the 4th amendment that aren't there. If you look at the phrasing of the text, which focuses on "searches" and "seizures" of "persons, houses, papers, and effects" it's clear that the 4th amendment prohibits the government from doing what would be a common law trespass (to the person, to real property, or to chattels). It's based on property rights, not privacy.

Re:Maps Showing Where FBI Planes Are Watching from Above by Zigurd on Monday April 11, 2016 @10:42AM (#11471778)
> Observing someone in public is not a trespass, no matter how much you do it.

That's because it would be stalking.

Re:Maps Showing Where FBI Planes Are Watching from Above by sixothree on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:29AM (#11469642)
So it's completely legal to follow someone every place they go? I thought that was very illegal.
Re:Maps Showing Where FBI Planes Are Watching from Above by nommm-nommm on Monday April 11, 2016 @12:57AM (#11469717)
Harassing someone is generally illegal, which can include following them around, usually to intimidate them.

If you are following someone in the matter the police would they won't know they are being followed, which is part of what private investigators do.

Just don't harass them. If they catch you and tell you to stop and you don't - then you are veering into harassment territory.