News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by tptacek on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @01:01AM (#114674)
I'll be the contrarian here.

Unless you control the company, or the founders (or whatever the "board"-equivalent is at this nascent stage) are dumb, no matter what the paper stock agreement is, you can get screwed.

All you people with private company options plans are pretty much deluding yourselves about your recourse in the event of an unfavorable (to you) liquidation. The pecking order is, latest VC, VC, founders, every executive, and then you. No matter what your paper says, everyone above you in that chain can screw you over.

I've seen this go both ways. Companies with 20-30MM+ in revenue have been acquired by $5Bn gorillas, and the VCs and m-team walked with everything but a few thousand dollars. And companies have gone public and larded everyone with windfall options.

If you want to have some idea of how much your "equity" might be worth, you need to know not only how many shares you're getting, but how many shares are outstanding, how that pool is going to change after multiple rounds of funding, and, finally, how much the company will liquidate for. A bunch of those questions are basically unknowable.

So, you can work for people with this sketchy answer, or you can work for the people who make shit up about their equity to make your questions go away, but in neither case is the answer to this question really helping you. Do you trust the team or not? Is the project worth it even if you don't trust them?

Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by neilc on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @03:12AM (#114728)
I think it is still a serious red flag if you're offered a job at a startup but the equity terms haven't been settled yet. Sure, even if the terms are fixed, it is possible to get screwed down the road. And of course, employees are typically the last people to cash out if a liquidation event occurs. So what? A written agreement in a nascent company might not be worth a whole lot, but it's worth considerably more than a verbal one. If you aren't promised a specific equity stake in writing (in addition to information about the total # of outstanding shares etc.), then I'd assume you're not getting any equity -- you're probably not going to be too far off.

Furthermore, the fact that the equity hasn't been arranged is a sign that these entrepreneurs seem pretty clueless. I doubt that any reputable investor would sign on to invest in a company like that, for example. Not settling the equity up front doesn't "save time", as you've suggested elsewhere: sorting out the equity after the fact is likely to be more time-consuming and contentious than doing it earlier, when the company is smaller and consensus is easier to reach.

Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by davidw on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @04:36AM (#114755)
Agreed - of course you can get screwed, but by running things that way, the owner is showing how he operates, and it's a warning sign.
Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by tptacek on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @01:33PM (#115052)
You're out of your fucking mind if you think this is the major risk of joining a startup.

If you want to see how the "owner" operates the company, ask questions about the sales pipeline. Ask for concrete answers about what happens when the "big customer" cuts them out of the budget.

If you don't know how the company's cash flows work, and you're reading tea leaves about the founders state of mind from meaningless equity numbers, then you're just wanking.

Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by davidw on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @03:41PM (#115182)
I'm simply stating that by not being clear and decisive from the get-go, you can only expect more of same later on, possibly when it's more painful.

I didn't say anything about a 'major risk', just that it's a hint about how the guy operates. Could be he's wishy washy, or that he's playing games, it's not possible to know.

Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by nostrademons on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @11:29AM (#114926)
There are degrees of screwedness, though. If you have an option plan in writing, you at least have some guarantees about "If you're with the company over this vesting schedule, and if we don't get acquired or go out of business before then, and if we aren't diluted by multiple rounds of funding, and if we have a liquidity event, and if you exercise your options, you'll get this much of the company." That's a lot of ifs, but it's still a helluva lot more than having nothing. Plus, the inability of the founders to make this hard decisions makes me wonder what other hard decisions they won't be able to make.
Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by tptacek on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @01:36PM (#115057)
No. Even with an options plan, and especially but not necessarily if they've taken VC, our friend can get screwed in the event of a takeover.

But that's not what's going to happen. What's really going to happen is, it's going to take more than 4 years for the company to approach any kind of liquidity (really, what's going to happen is, the company is going to go out of business like most software startups, but never mind that). But our friend is going to get bored and leave before 4 years are up.

Are you seriously suggesting that 3 years from now, when he leaves to take a $200,000 job, that he buy private company options? Because if he doesn't, option plan or no, he gets nothing.

Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by nostrademons on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @04:19PM (#115220)
"Are you seriously suggesting that 3 years from now, when he leaves to take a $200,000 job, that he buy private company options?"

If the company is doing well, and the strike price is favorable, then yes. You don't get a chance to buy stock in privately-held fast growers often...

Of course, the far more likely option is that the company's gone out of business or is going nowhere. But I did mention a whole bunch of conditions for seeing any sort of payoff from options, one of which was "if the company doesn't go out of business or get acquired first" (another was "and the employee exercises his options", so I don't really see the point of this comment..)

I'm not arguing that employees don't get screwed...look, I've worked at a couple of companies with stock options, and never saw a penny out of them. Last time I went jobhunting I took the one that paid the higher salary rather than the one with options for that reason. I'm saying that other things being equal, he's more likely to get screwed at the startup that won't put anything in writing than the one with a written option plan. I don't see how that's really debatable...

Re:Ask YC: Thinking of joining a startup - is this a red-flag? by tptacek on Wednesday February 13, 2008 @05:24PM (#115281)
I'm a vote for never, ever buying options in a private company, unless you're confident you know what the outcome is going to be --- that there's an imminent liquidity event, that you know what the numbers are, you know the VC's prefs, and you know where your shares are relative to the outstanding shares.

When I left my last company, they told me I was crazy for not buying my vested options. Multiple times over the following 3 years, coworkers would IM me and say, "I really wish I had convinced you to buy those options! Big stuff is coming!"

And it has: they bought another company, got revenues to the point where only 3 companies in the world can afford to buy them, and are digging in for the long haul towards an eventual IPO, where all the shares will get reset anyways.

That's not even close to a horror story. The real horror story is, you buy your options, the company exits 2 years later, management and investors get all the money, and current employees share a retention pool. You put your money in VFINX, you get 3-5% returns. You put your money in private company options, you lose it all.