Re:Are you a grammar pedant? This might be why
by jeremysmyth on Monday April 11, 2016 @07:58AM
(#11470923)
While these criticisms are valid, you shouldn't use them to dismiss S&W entirely. It contains many good observations[1] about the English language.
[1] Sadly, many are voiced prescriptively despite the fact that neither S&W nor any other manual of style can claim to be the final arbiter of our ever-evolving language.
The Wikipedia entry mentions "The Elements of Style" by White and Strunk as one of the sources of the rule. The manual has been criticised by professional linguists, who noted that White and Strunk didn't even seem to understand what constitutes a passive voice (while discouraging their use). The manual also contains other silly prescriptions, like avoiding split infinitives.