Re:How an Idea to Develop a Safer, Smart Gun Backfired
by robert_tweed on Saturday April 09, 2016 @09:00PM
(#11464262)
> "Always" was always more important than "never"
That's exactly the opposite of what you want from a nuclear trigger system. I mean if you actually need to launch, it's already past the point where it's going to do anything helpful. What you need is something that everyone in the world unquestioningly believes will always work, even if that isn't entirely true.
OTOH, if it ever goes off by mistake, that not good. Not good at all.
(The book is a great read and I recommend it, even if it makes you wonder how we got to 2016 as well off as we did. "Always" was always more important than "never")
EDIT: article about the book, + quote: " In fact, it is easy to design weapons so that they can never fire by accident or unauthorized use. It is equally easy to design them so that they will always fire when the order is given. But it is extraordinarily difficult to meet both criteria at once—what is known as the “always/never” problem."
from http://www.thenation.com/article/eric-schlosser-and-illusion...