News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AT&T might just have the best 3G network in the US by mortenjorck on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @03:29PM (#1146334)
What I don't understand is why AT&T doesn't just upgrade or build some towers in SF. As you point out, it's an absurd statistical outlier for their metro networks, and the peninsula isn't even all that big compared to some sprawling places like LA, from which I've never read any complaints about AT&T service.
Re:AT&T might just have the best 3G network in the US by jsz0 on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @03:54PM (#1146393)
Not sure how it is in SF but in most of the US it's very difficult to get the permits/public approval required to build new towers. Existing towers have strict load limits for weight and wind resistance and often require structural testing/upgrades for any work to be done. Verizon seems to manage so I'm not acquitting AT&T of any responsibility here but it's another example of US laws & regulations being incredibly unfriendly to infrastructure development. Of course these towers should be safe so some of these regulations are completely valid. I'm more concerned about the privately owned towers whose owners simply don't want to spend the money on new construction or the communities where a small group of civic minded folks are able to stop the construction of new towers for the sole reason that their appearance offends them. We're going to get left behind in this world if we keep this mindset up.
Re:AT&T might just have the best 3G network in the US by chrisbolt on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @05:31PM (#1146653)
It's bad in SF, but it's not much better in LA. No reception in the hills, no 3G on the sunset strip, and I constantly get spotty reception and dropped calls.
Re:AT&T might just have the best 3G network in the US by gojomo on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @03:43PM (#1146372)
It may not be all AT&T's fault. SF has some grassroots groups that reflexively oppose all new radio towers. See for example:

http://www.antennafreeunion.org/

http://www.no-celltower.com/