I started/ran silverfishlongboarding.com for a few years and the forums became very popular. Even so, it never made more than a couple hundred a month off Adsense.
Eventually we got rid of Adsense and started selling ads directly. Within a few months we were bringing in several thousand a month. It was much more time consuming, but it worked. I sold the site a couple years ago, but I keep in touch with the new owners and I know that at least one of them is making a living full time off it.
Remember when the dot-com bubble burst? The fallout was littered with sites that had audiences, but no effective means of monetizing.
Most of the dot-com failures were just straight out bad businesses, making a loss on each unit but making up for it in volume. Pets.com is the obvious example, selling cases of dog food at a loss because the shipping cost more than the dog food. The common theme of the dot-com failures was the desire to grow as big as possible as fast as possible, regardless of everything else.
A niche audience is completely different to a mass audience. They are inherently valuable by merit of being a niche. A list of pet owners isn't worth very much, but a list of people who own German Shepherds with arthritis is. The reason should be obvious to anyone who has ever sold anything. Just the list of names is worth proper money, let alone the community and the goodwill and trust that it carries.
You probably aren't going to find a homerun scalable business model, but there are dozens of sustainable small businesses that could be built on such a base.
Hell, it's jackets that were in movies right? Don't netflix, amazon and apple allow for affiliate links to the movie? Depending on the traffic that could add up.