News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by pnelly on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @06:56AM (#1145210)
good article, how can a system based on greed, corruption, and imaginary wealth survive? The U.S. has concentrated less and less on production and innovation, and needs to refocus it's efforts it it's going to get out of this hole. Energy is a great example of where production and innovation is now needed, and could revive the U.S. Economy. I hope this comes to pass.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @07:13AM (#1145229)
not trying to single you out, but your post is a good example of the type of rhetoric that i dislike on economic subjects. "feel good" statements about greed and corruption discourage the kind of dispassionate analysis we actually need.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by hga on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @07:59AM (#1145284)
I'll go further: all economic systems are based on greed and corruption because those are parts of human nature. The question is how to you harness the former and limit the latter. We seem to do a very good job with both when compared to the rest of the world.

In terms of the bottom lines of economic growth, standards of living and employment, again, we do much better than the rest of the world (I'm not going to count the special case of China emerging from decades of communism, returning a billion plus people to the world market is a one time thing ... and their recent grow should be weighted against how much they lost economically during the previous period).

Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:17AM (#1145296)
I think one of the underlying problems is the fact that economics gets described with such loaded phrases as greed and corruption. such thinking, as if parts of human nature are easily described as "bad" or "good", is what leads to much of the harmful meddling to begin with. it makes it much easier to get confused between intended ends and actual effects. basically, economic problems aren't ethical ones, even though they can cause ethical problems.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by akadien on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @08:51AM (#1145350)
I'll go even further: all economic systems are based on greed, of which corruption is a manifestation, and fear. Those are the two basic emotional responses to finance, and the basic question is how do you not fall prey to mental errors because of them. And in too many cases, people use numeracy to force others into making mental errors because of those two basic human emotions, not to mitigate against them. I've started an open blog at financialpreparedness.com to rant and rave about this and other sorts of things.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by anamax on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @10:44AM (#1145572)
>I'll go even further: all economic systems are based on greed, of which corruption is a manifestation, and fear.

Lots of things are manifested as greed, many good.

You also forgot envy.

I'm being greedy when I'm worrying about what I've got.

I'm being envious when I'm worrying about what you've got.

I claim that envy causes far more problems than greed.

Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by hga on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @11:26AM (#1145689)
You need to go further:

Jealousy is where you're thinking of what the other has and you want it.

Envy is the same except you know you can't get it.

Since envy gives no one a (material) benefit, whereas greed gives one or both sides benefits, yep, it's absolutely the worst. Of the 7 deadly sins, envy is the only one without any direct reward.

Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by anamax on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @10:43AM (#1145570)
>I'll go even further: all economic systems are based on greed, of which corruption is a manifestation, and fear.

Lots of things are manifested as greed, many good.

You also forgot envy.

I'm being greedy when I'm worrying about what I've got.

I'm being envious when I'm worrying about what you've got.

I claim that envy causes far more problems than greed.

Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by hga on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @09:39AM (#1145427)
Could you give us 1-5 paragraphs on your thesis that "people use numeracy to force others into making mental errors" based on greed and fear? I've not heard of that concept before.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @10:25AM (#1145534)
I think the gist of it is that people use difficult to understand things as a way of both signaling competence and of intimidating others into not questioning them. think mutual funds who leech off their clients with worse returns than the S&P500. over time the best ways of doing this have been refined, think of the way media outlets use statistics that, while not exactly lies, are at best not the whole truth. and not 1 person in 100 has the competence to debunk the nonsense.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by hga on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @11:23AM (#1145680)
You'll need to give me another example. Year to year returns after fees from a mutual fund vs. S&P500 is too trivial as long as there are no tax implications (and you can get the latter from your CPA if it isn't a retirement investment).

We're not talking complicated statistics where everything starting with the assumptions must be suspected, we're talking N% return in X year.

Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @11:31PM (#1147272)
that was a simple example where even though the numbers are trivial to interpret people still make gross errors. now look at the mortgage market for instance, where people basically have no idea how home financing works. I hear all the time about how some couple "discovered' that you could avoid brokerage fees by getting a license yourself at trivial time and money investment.
Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger by akadien on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @10:42AM (#1145566)
That's exactly what I meant! Thanks for saying it so well.