Both Munger and Buffett have a habit of stealing your wallet while telling you you're an idiot for letting them do it. The article and the Goldman deal are reflections of that attitude.
You'd hope someone like Buffet, with his cache and savvy could suggest some reasonable ways to end "too big to fail." All things right now make me think we'll have another bust in a couple years, nothing is fundamentally different.
The Goldman warrants are an option to purchase an additional $5 billion of stock at $115 per share, any time in the next 5 (now 4) years. Basically, they're a plain vanilla call option.
What's really interesting about those warrants is that they behave identically to an equity purchase, only without the downside. Berkshire literally can't lose money. Plus, if the warrants are ever exercised, then Berkshire simply gets more equity. It never gets tarted up with default swaps and tranches and triggers and all that crap. The deal is the complete opposite of the 'casino' mentality that Munger is decrying.
So, yeah, you might be technically correct. However, you've also got to look at the spirit of the thing.
No. They were derivatives. Goldman was to pay those heavy dividends by executing credit default swaps they had purchased from AIG. Trouble is, the securities underlying the swaps were overcommitted, meaning the swap prices would be driven way down in an open market. And Goldman didn't own the securities. And the securities hadn't necessarily defaulted. And AIG had no money.
This was solved by the Munger/Buffet helping arrange for the taxpayer to pay off AIG's gambles at 100% without Goldman even delivering the securities underlying the swaps.
Make no mistake, the Goldman deal was a naked derivative play combined with brazen government corruption.
However, my understanding was that from Berkshire's perspective, it was a straight equity investment for preferred stock. They didn't really care where the dividend cash came from, so long as they got paid. So, if it was a derivative play, it was an indirect one. Berkshire never had those default swaps on its books.
That's how I remember it going down, at least. It's entirely possible that I got some of this wrong.
It also backfired on him at the height of the credit crunch. While he was smart enough to write the contracts in such a way that he didn't need to post collateral, he didn't account for the way that someone looking to hedge their counterparty risk with him would behave. When the market collapsed, the buyers of the puts proceeded to short both the equity and debt of Berkshire to protect their investment. http://crookery.blogspot.com/2008/11/valuing-large-options-i... and http://crookery.blogspot.com/2008/05/warren-buffetts-vega-ga... have some of the technical details, and http://www.portfolio.com/views/blogs/market-movers/2008/11/2... has a good general explanation of what went wrong.
Buffett may not have been in the casino all the time, but he had plenty of side bets that could have wiped him out.
PS: Leverage means making money from money you don't have ex: loan on rental property. But to classify as highly leveraged you need to risk 10x or more money than you actually have.
The "money you don't have" part of the definition of leverage isn't necessarily money that you must pay back like a loan or bonds; it can also be money that you may have to pay under certain conditions. Writing naked puts and selling reinsurance is the latter.
From http://community.reinsurance.org/Data/Leverage/Und%20Lvg%202... , we can see that Berkshire's 2005 leverage ratio was 143%. That's fairly low for a reinsurance company, and Berkshire is not highly leveraged.
However, I'm still going to maintain that the marginal increase in leverage from the specific derivatives deal I mentioned was rather high. Most insurance companies have noncyclical liabilities (e.g. the mortality rate doesn't increase in recessions) and procyclical assets(e.g. stocks and bonds that fall in recessions). The sale of puts added a procyclical liability, increasing Berkshire's leverage at the margin.
Thanks for the catch. See my edit above for more.
Berkshire did not loan the $5 billion and receive the options until well after the financial mess...
This is effectively wrong, since the TARP funds were issued after the investment. See the link at the edit above.
In any case, I think that if there anyone who has demonstrated an immense understanding of the American economy for the last 50 years, it's Warren Buffet and his partner Charlie Munger. There is no one/duo that has been more successful at investing and predicting long term economic scenarios over this time period.
The parable is designed to highlight the folly of having 25% of your GDP devoted to what is essentially gambling. I don't think the story is weakened by the author having invested money in one of the 'casinos'.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/06...
I was arguing it's possible to not agree with the way the world works, but still exploit it. Of course buffet shouldn't pay taxes until the laws are changed. Hs's publicly argued many times that taxes are too low on rich people, just as he argues derivatibes are net destructive to society - it desn't mean he should not deal in derivatives if he sees an opportunity.
EDIT: Fixed duplicate words.
Also, Buffet advocates higher taxes that the won't pay and that he benefits from.
Consider the estate tax. He pushes it, but his estate will never be taxed. He also makes quite a bit of money selling insurance to help people pay estate taxes.
Yes, he benefits directly from estate taxes.
The estate tax doesn't even kick in unless the inheritance is over something like 2 million dollars. That is one "anti tax" issue that I seriously don't understand. Seems like that should be literally the last tax that gets cut, why not cut the income tax if we're cutting taxes?
It is often portrayed as something only the super wealthy need to worry about, but plenty of farmland goes on sale in the midwest because taxes can't be covered.
"In the news yesterday, Goldman Sachs (GS) announced that Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A), Buffett's investing vehicle, will purchase $5B worth of perpetual preferred shares with a 10% dividend being paid in return for exclusive use of this capital injection. Not only does Berkshire get a dividend nearly double that of Canadian bank issued perpetuals, but the holding company also receives warrants to purchase $5B of common stock at $115 during the next five years."
So let's put it together.
* Buffett and Munger buy tons of stock in the above mentioned "casino".
* The casino loses big.
* Casino gets huge tax bucks from you and me to cover its loses and pay huge bonuses to itself.
* The tax money flows back to Berkshire via the holdings listed above, and form thence to Buffett and Munger.
* Munger writes folksy article damning "casino gambling".
For those who weren't aware, Buffett was a director of Goldman for many years. You know, the years when all this latest crap was happening. The years when he and Munger must have talked at least once a week. Those years.
EDIT: Buffett is the largest individual investor in GS, and was apparently asked (on that basis) to join the board, but apparently never did. My bad. On the other hand, his involvement in TARP is even worse that I knew:
From http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2009/04/05/65496/buffett-champion... :
"Buffett's company, Berkshire Hathaway, hasn't received any of that federal aid, but Berkshire, based in Omaha, Neb., owns stock valued at more than $13 billion in the top recipients of TARP funds, including Goldman Sachs Group, US Bancorp, American Express and Bank of America, which analysts all thought were in deep trouble before TARP was approved in October."
I'm a huge believer in economic freedom, i.e., the free market. I only wish that most large businesses were. It's so much easier for them to rent-seek.