Re:"Basically, It's Over" by Charlie Munger
by Tichy on Tuesday February 23, 2010 @06:51AM
(#1145206)
I am not saying the story is wrong, so I don't "disprove by one liner". I don't like the device for manipulating opinion, that's all.
If you read such a beautiful fairytale, you can nod along feeling comfy all the way (maybe sitting in front of a cosy fireplace among friends).
Overall, I am pretty sure opinions are not formed by logic, but by factions - we believe things because it benefits us and makes us belong to our faction. So to create a comfy fireplace fairytale setting is simply a manipulative device. I feel it is a good idea to be wary of such approaches, just as an anecdote is interesting, but should not be sufficient basis for judgment.
Maybe you like it, maybe you don't. "Proof by fiction" is simple mischaracterization.