News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RISC-V Offers Simple, Modular ISA by ShinyCyril on Thursday April 07, 2016 @11:29AM (#11448018)
I haven't checked out the high-level synthesis part, but I've been using Vivado for a project recently and it's absolutely horrible. To name some of the issues I've had;

- Memory leaks (grows from about 1GB to 11GB and starts swapping in a couple of minutes when editing existing IP)

- Single-threaded synthesis is slow (though isn't limited to Vivado specifically)

- Failing after 20 minutes of synthesis because of errors that would be easy to check at the start

- Placing debug cores can result in needing to synthesise, find something went wrong, delete debug core, re-synthesise, re-add debug nets, synthesise again...

- Aggressive caching results in it trying to find nets which were changed and no longer exist, despite re-creating the IP in question from scratch

- Vivado creates a ridiculous amount of temporary files and is a royal pain to use with version control (there is an entire document which details the methods to use if you want to create a project to be stored under version control)

I've been playing around with IceStorm for the iCE40 device and it's an absolute joy to use: fast, stable and simple. I appreciate that there are a lot of complex tools and reports which Vivado provides, but I would much rather use an open source tool like IceStorm for synthesis alongside the advanced tools from Vivado.

There are no comments on this comment yet.