Re:Why I love ugly, messy interfaces
by ageektrapped on Thursday April 07, 2016 @11:23AM
(#11447962)
> I think people often confuse "simple" with "pretty".
Oh man, this.
Even richer is confusing usable with pretty. I guess nowadays people say "user experience" instead of usability, or the extremely unfortunate: UX.
Simple usually covers the very first prototype version, but then there are always requests for complicating the feature set so you can't have a simple interface anymore.
Joel Spolsky had a conference talk about this once (can't remember where I saw it). There is a tension between simplicity and power: some need simplicity; others, power. It's a spectrum. What developers and designers should strive for is elegance so that one can move along the spectrum without noticing it.
It does what it sets out to do, without pretension or fluff. If that's considered unsimplistic, I don't know what the word means.
I think the argument is a little different for Photoshop, but I'm not a user and frankly I do find it confusing. But like the mixer analogy, a professional tool should sometimes sacrifice simplicity for utility.