News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I love ugly, messy interfaces by ryanbrunner on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:44AM (#11446455)
For craigslist specifically, I think people often confuse "simple" with "pretty". Craigslist is a remarkably simple interface. I've never seen anyone - regardless of age or proficiency with computers - get confused while using it.

It does what it sets out to do, without pretension or fluff. If that's considered unsimplistic, I don't know what the word means.

I think the argument is a little different for Photoshop, but I'm not a user and frankly I do find it confusing. But like the mixer analogy, a professional tool should sometimes sacrifice simplicity for utility.

Re:Why I love ugly, messy interfaces by ageektrapped on Thursday April 07, 2016 @11:23AM (#11447962)
> I think people often confuse "simple" with "pretty".

Oh man, this.

Even richer is confusing usable with pretty. I guess nowadays people say "user experience" instead of usability, or the extremely unfortunate: UX.

Simple usually covers the very first prototype version, but then there are always requests for complicating the feature set so you can't have a simple interface anymore.

Joel Spolsky had a conference talk about this once (can't remember where I saw it). There is a tension between simplicity and power: some need simplicity; others, power. It's a spectrum. What developers and designers should strive for is elegance so that one can move along the spectrum without noticing it.