I just checked and I unfortunately do not have the epicurious rating data. I did just check their website and they have a guide for rating 1-Okay 2-Good 3-Delicious 4-Exceptional.
Their rating system is not broken to the degree of these other websites.
Of course, with any crowd sourced system it is good to take the time to really read through who you are getting your trusted advice from. I still remember reading a review of a Korean restaurant on yelp that had two or three one star reviews because "they did not have sushi".