Mixergy's about successful entrepreneurs. That's niche. That just doesn't have the potential size to be pushing a large enough volume that sponsorships matter. To get a larger audience it'd be necessary to expand the subject matter, and that would dilute the value of the site itself.
A better option might be to interview successful figures about how they became successful, and expand more outside of tech entrepreneurship. There's been a couple of interviews like that, and weighting it 1/3 tech, 2/3 successful figures in other arenas, there's a much larger potential audience.
At the same time, keeping the laser-like focus on the nuts and bolts and numbers would craft a high-end audience, the kind that advertisers absolutely love.
http://money.cnn.com/2009/09/25/magazines/fortune/charlie_ro...
He actually doesn't make a huge ton of money (he'd do well to hire sponsorship sales staff IMO).
Interviews are tough to monetize because the benefits are pretty intangible.
The Charlie Rose model is better I think. Where you do long 1 hr interviews and get sponsorships to help pay for costs. It depends on growing an audience but it can work.
Another idea -- what if Andrew was able to put together conferences/events given the ties he has. He could charge for admission and have a panel of start up entrepreneurs where he interviews and moderates Q&As between the audience and entrepreneurs. Conferences are generally pretty profitable and could be worth exploring.