News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by tptacek on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @12:50PM (#11439968)
It is, but isn't it also the case that secret court filings are as old as the US courts? How else would espionage prosecutions work? Similarly, how would complicated organized crime investigations work without secrecy? Isn't the alternative that prosecutors get exactly one bite at the apple, and if they're wrong, the target of the investigation is tipped off?

The case that ultimately appears before the court, of course, needs to be transparent. And the evidence collected by the prosecution must be made available to the defendant. But this isn't that.

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by fiatmoney on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:07PM (#11440084)
"Secret court filings" that are hidden from the defense during a trial are ridiculously uncommon. Sealed filings for, eg, warrants are common. They are typically made available to the defense & the public for the trial. Otherwise the evidence amounts to "trust us, we're the government".

In counter-espionage cases, it is very common for the government to balance concern about disclosing its methods with likelihood of a conviction. If they fuck up the investigation and tip off the target before the trial, or tip off other targets during the trial, it's not the court's job to give them a do-over.

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by tptacek on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:08PM (#11440095)
Yes. Am I misreading this case? It seems like evidence was furnished, and that the complaint here is that the original sealed warrant wasn't. The defense objects because the original FISA warrant could have been flawed, and if it was, the evidence deployed in the trial could have been excluded.
Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by fiatmoney on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:15PM (#11440136)
"Evidence" isn't just "the parts of the evidence the prosecution wanted to use".

How is the defense supposed to cross-examine the person who gathered the evidence when they can't investigate the circumstances under which it was gathered? How are they supposed to make a cogent argument that it was not a properly issued warrant unless they can see it? How are they supposed to argue that even if the the warrant was proper, the evidence gathered was not under the scope of the warrant? How are they supposed to get access to other exculpatory evidence that would have been collected under the warrant, that the prosecution declined to use?

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by tptacek on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:22PM (#11440201)
I understand the argument, but is that what actually happened here? My understanding is that the one thing the defense doesn't have is the whole justification for entering the defendant's personal space in the first place.

I could be misreading!

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by fiatmoney on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @03:43PM (#11441342)
It sure looks like you are. "Gartenlaub wants to see the warrant in his case so he can challenge it as based on false information and therefore invalid." According to the article the warrant itself and the filings in support of it are unavailable to the defense. That is essential to making arguments on the legality of the warrant in the first place, the scope of the evidence gathered to the warrant, and factual arguments derived from the process of executing the warrant.

(Example! The warrant included Device X, because Secret FBI Source Y said it had classified information. The device was searched, but contained no such information; in fact it had been completely wiped. This lets the defense argue that the FBI knew the source was unreliable, or that the evidence found was exculpatory (eg, evidence the target had been hacked to plant the child porn). None of this is available to the defense.)

The government says that the evidence gathered in the warrant has been made available. They could very well be lying, or simply mistaken, and it's impossible to investigate. Regardless, it is only part of the issue.

The process here is that the judge looked at it the government's arguments, without involving the defense, and said "yeah, it looks good, trust me / them".

(Which, incidentally, is completely contrary to the notion of the judge as a neutral arbiter rather than an inquisitor working for the government. Not surprising when the FISA court itself essentially operates in that capacity.)

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by tptacek on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @05:25PM (#11442263)
Sorry, I think I'm just being imprecise.

I understand the nature of his argument: he'd like to challenge the warrant to get the CP evidence excluded. He can't, because the warrant is secret; his CP criminal trial judge validated it, but in a normal case, he'd have the chance to evaluate himself.

What I perceived you to have been claiming was that the defendant additionally doesn't know the actual provenance of the evidence. Which computer did it come from? How does he know the FBI didn't simply make it up?

It's that latter claim that I'm pushing back on.

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by fiatmoney on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @06:02PM (#11442530)
The warrant establishes the provenance, it's the whole point!
Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by tptacek on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @06:18PM (#11442635)
I feel like we're about to argue about the meaning of the word "provenance". I meant it as "where the evidence came from". You mean it as "the legal authority required to collect it". Both uses are valid, but I meant the former.
Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by fiatmoney on Thursday April 07, 2016 @12:59AM (#11444838)
The law is not being kept secret. The facts supporting the issuance of the warrant and the circumstances of its execution are. That is the causal definition of "where the evidence came from". That in and of itself is evidence.

"I first heard about the defendant's shenanigans when I was attending my support group for compulsive liars, from Joe, the defendant's bitter ex-husband. As I recall he was covered in blood at the time." That is a factual circumstance related to the issuance of the warrant that would be relevant to the case, not just the issuance of the warrant itself.

This is not a difficult distinction, it's one you're trying for whatever reason to ignore.

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by Spooky23 on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:09PM (#11440101)
There is a difference between a sealed proceeding and a secret proceeding.

With a sealed event, the judge is the barrier. With a secret event, you need to be in the priesthood of people cleared to know secrets to even ask about the matter.

Secrecy in effect makes information contraband. That's a problem in a criminal trial where the accused is presumed innocent.

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by apeace on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:44PM (#11440359)
> The case that ultimately appears before the court, of course, needs to be transparent. And the evidence collected by the prosecution must be made available to the defendant. But this isn't that.

This is that. The defense is being told that there was probable cause to issue a search warrant, but they are not being told what the cause was and are not allowed to see the warrant.

They have to take the government's word that the defendant's rights aren't being violated. Not how our court system is supposed to work!

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by sneak on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:03PM (#11440057)
For espionage, your argument makes a little bit of sense.

When they cross over into non-espionage routine prosecutions, this stuff should get thrown the fuck out.

A warrant that can't be challenged for legality by the accused is a clear denial of due process.

Also, scroll down the thread. The CP prosecution was used as a stick to further their espionage prosecution for which it turns out the guy was innocent.

Re:How a federal spy case turned into a child pornography pr... by ekianjo on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @01:03PM (#11440060)
> Similarly, how would complicated organized crime investigations work without secrecy?

Secrecy is one thing, however the key issue here is the lack of civilian oversight. The whole FISA system is behind closed doors without any third party representative to confirm the lawfulness of investigations.

That's what makes a difference between police state methods and due process: the fact that there is somehow some decentralization of responsibilities.