https://www.yubico.com/2015/02/big-debate-2048-4096-yubicos-...
> While it is true that a longer key provides better security, we have shown that by doubling the length of the key from 2048 to 4096, the increase in bits of security is only 18, a mere 16%. Moreover, besides requiring more storage, longer keys also translate into increased CPU usage and higher power consumption.
There is argument to be made that 4096-bit RSA keys are unnecessary. But this isn't it.
https://www.gnupg.org/faq/gnupg-faq.html#no_default_of_rsa40...
Shorter version: RSA-4096 is roughly 28bits over RSA-2048 (112 vs 140 bits).
If I had started with Yubikeys when I started with GPG I would have used 2048 and updated when the Smartcard technology improved.
Additionally I have not a huge need for gpg messages on my Smartphone, so its not a big problem.
Those are very hard to temper with, while USB sticks are trivial to temper with (be it accidentally or by someone with malicious intent).
It's all about proportionality. If your GPG-key (and SSH-key) grants you access to servers containing sensitive data placed there in good faith (think medical records), then having your private keys stored somewhere they can't be copied from without physically obtaining (and destroying) the keys is totally justified.
And if you are doing it because, well, you can, then you are helping in making this knowledge available to the wider community.
I think pushing the bounds and evaluating usablity, maybe finding bugs is important. I still mostly do it for fun. I really like thinking threw different thread models and security systems.
For example, compare the security gained by keybases new system (NaCL, device keys, tracking) with my old gpg/smartcard/wot system.
Currently their is no way to use your 4096bit key over NFC. The Yubikey NEO only supports 2048bit keys and the Yubikey 4 does not support NFC. So you have to either use a secondary key or expose yourself and put your private key on your phone.
I fully expect Yubico to realease a Yubikey 4 with NFC sometime this year, and this would enable my optimal solution:
I have a Smartphone and a Laptop. To securly use them, I should have 3 Yubikeys, 1 of them a Nano plus 2 USB Sticks. The Nano is always plugged into my laptop, exept for exeptional situations. One of the large Yubikeys is on my keyring, the other is at home as a backup. One USB stick is only for the Master Key and I would bring it along if I expected to use certification. The other USB Stick is a poor backup and savly stored at home, it also contains the Revocation Key.
All this is pretty expensive and not really all that easy to set up but if you do it you have the great benefits, like ähh well äähh I guess other crypto nerds might think its cool.