Or is it okay as long as they get ad-sense money?
I think a strict definition of MFA is always going to be a little grey, but there's clearly something wrong with pages that are nothing other than widgets, scraped content and the like.
Not to say that Calacanis is the man, but to illustrate that rules are there to suit the rule makers and in this case, it suits the rule makers to ignore their own rules.
i accidentally got one of mine blocked when playing around with some random software that produced a site that was somehow against their TOS. i didn't have it live long, but long enough for the spiders to grab and flag. still waiting on a reconsideration request.
why not mahalo? who knows. if i had to venture a guess, i'd say that the larger the site and the more revenue google sees from that site due to adwords and the like, the higher up the chain the decision to block it has to come from.
Although this is perfectly legal, there is quite a few big sites that scrapes Wikipedia and adds ad-sense. If you are searching for a narrow topic, page 1-2 is WP and WP copies.
As a sidenote - I see that Google Search has upvotes, comments and deletes in the search - yet it does not seem as if anyone uses it. Why? Why can't the user at least blacklist sites?
It would be good to have a "remove all pages with Wikipedia content" button on searches. Sometimes it seems half the results are simply Wikipedia copies.
And at the higher level they absolutely do penalize people individually to send a message. Watch the opening of this video if you think otherwise http://blogoscoped.com/archive/2008-07-08-n14.html
These actions appear to be conscious choices to make sure that google will index these pages, which according to several sources, have nothing but "scraped" content and are therefore spam.
Now, stealing other peoples work, that is obviously Mahalos doing and should be a case for the court.
I'm not really sure what the point with this article is. Mahalo spams google - so what? It's up to them to do this and up to google to prevent it. Business is business, even on the internet.
If Mahalo’s traffic was utter crap, it would be dropped.
That's not even close to true. If it were, there would be no AdSense for parked pages program. Their eye is still very much on their own bottom line, not the advertisers.
http://www.emarketer.com/Article.aspx?R=1007053
As an extension of that, sites which get most of their traffic from search often have the highest ad CPM values because the ad targeting is so relevant on the AdSense ads. And this is true even moreso now that Google is also using the referrer for ad targeting
http://adsense.blogspot.com/2010/02/better-contextual-matchi...
Scraper sites do quite well on the ad revenues front because most of the traffic is search driven, and because the content ends up so bad that the ads look all the more appealing.
I know for a fact that Google is balancing advertiser ROI against advertising spend and ensuring that they don't upset the apple cart.
However you are absolutely right that Google is maximizing their profit – having the ROI numbers in hand lets them drive down overall sales-from-adsense margins while still keeping the customer.
So my original point is that if Mahalo was flat out non-performing crap, it would be tossed.
An argument could be made though that they use the Mahalo stuff to grow ad inventory, while balancing out the ROI to their advantage since it likely converts on the lower end of the scale.
* thousands of AdWords advertisers that have paid for their ads to be matched with content sites, not scraper pages with a huge ad to text ratio
* thousands of publishers whose work is being scraped, aggregated and outranked without as much as a backlink
* millions of web searchers that are hitting these pages instead of the real sources of the content they were searching for
And calling out companies that harm the fabric of the web for everyone else is worth doing.