And that's true even if the indicator objectively performs relatively well, as long as there are innocent people affected. To go back to the current topic, banning all connections from certain countries is an effective way to cut down on fraud without decreasing sales too much; but that still screws over legitimate users from those countries.
It could be extrapolated from that same data that 'black males obeying speed limits' are just easier to obtain convictions on - after all one has not 'caught' a 'drug mule' until the alleged is convicted.
Studies have long shown it is easier to obtain convictions of black males, especially for drugs.
More importantly for LEO funding today: is money seized can be kept with less blowback if disadvantaged minorities are targeted.
Institutional & societal racism could perhaps better explain the statistic.
Competent criminals adapt their muling system, throwing a patsy to cops once in a while - 'everybody' gets some. Clearly the drugs still get through.
Assume:
- LEOs use profiling (based on statistical models) to target individuals who are not the subject of investigation but rather subjected to random stop/search/frisk.
- They catch some "bad guys" by following this model.
These assumptions are not dissimilar from the premise outlined in the grandparent post.
Now, let's say the statistical model throws up "20-25 year old preppie white guy with glasses, called Peter" either through error or some odd outlier stat. If LEOs start to check out every 20-25 year old matching that description, sooner or later they're going to find drugs or a gun or a lot of cash or something. Their statistical model gets updated with these stats, and before long it becomes a truism that a disproportionate number of preppie Peters are criminals.
If you shine a spotlight somewhere, that's where you'll find what you're looking for.
I don't see anything with that sort of indicator. Call it profiling if you will, but I believe it's perfectly harmless assuming no excessive/unwarranted violence is used. That second part is important and drives the point of what I think actually needs to be addressed from the LE side. If it is indeed a bad or poor-performing indicator of a "drug mule", then it will go away eventually.