unsure if I agree. A lot of the user-space Unix/Linux Gui applications are built that way: command line interface first and GUI to control that. (the opposite of windows where often a cmdline interface is built to control the functionality provided by the GUI application).
So by that logic the majority of applications that have a GUI are labelled "not great products". Hmmmm ...
When it comes to Linux GUI applications, that's a pretty fair description. Understated and over-praising if anything.
Alternatives to PGP should probably include S/MIME and Signify, depending on what you want to do with it.
Soft disagree with that. Signal text and voice chat works just fine if all of your communicating party's machines are offline. (Well, I mean, obviously your voice call won't be answered, but otherwise...)
2. it absolutely doesn't require a smartphone, just a routable phone number, that can be a cell phone, a landline, a voip number or a google voice number: http://support.whispersystems.org/hc/en-us/articles/21247611...
I never said otherwise. What I said was:
> Signal text and voice chat works just fine if all of your communicating party's machines are offline.
This was in response to an assertion that Signal was designed for the "always-online" world. Signal works just fine when your contact is completely offline for extended periods of time.
I'm with moxie and Matthew Green (http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2014/08/whats-matter...), I think that we should seriously thank PGP for what it's done, understand what to do and what to not do (I believe Web of Trust is part of these) and take advantage of the fact that PGP has relatively few users to create something better.
If anyone else does it, they better write some really good papers about it and get reviews from the trusted people. (and they usually don't)
> The protocol reflects layers of cruft built up over the 20 years that it took for cryptography (and software engineering) to really come of age, and the fundamental architecture of PGP also leaves no room for now critical concepts like forward secrecy. [0]
> We could try to slap a GUI on top of it, but I don't believe great products are made that way. Good UX requires thinking about interactions all the way down to the protocol. [1]
[0] http://www.thoughtcrime.org/blog/gpg-and-me/
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9104562