News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by kragen on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:54PM (#11432697)
Let's quantify "a lot of energy": the dehumidification part is 210 watts per person. Maybe Clay can provide actual power consumption numbers that include the other parts of the system, such as filtration.

Typical coefficients of performance for air-source heat pumps, like air conditioners or dehumidifiers, are around 2; that means for every 2 joules of heat that it removes from the cold reservoir, it consumes a joule of electrical energy (dumping it as heat into the hot reservoir along with the heat it's pumping). The enthalpy of vaporization of water, at almost 41kJ/mol, is huge compared to the specific heat of air or even water itself, so that's a good approximation to how much heat you need to extract to condense the water. Water's molar mass is about 18 g/mol (two hydrogens of 1.0001 or so and an oxygen of 15.9994) so that works out to about 2.3kJ/g. At 10¢/kWh, this means your water costs 6.3¢/ℓ or US$78000/acrefoot.

This is a lot cheaper than bottled water, and a lot more expensive than what farmers can afford to pay for irrigation water, and a lot more expensive than reverse osmosis desalination, which I think is around $8000/acrefoot. (Corrections welcome!)

If we figure that a person needs 8 ℓ / day for cooking, drinking, and bathing (more or less what we use at Burning Man; if you're somewhere less hot and druggy then you might need less) which is about 210 watts. If a photovoltaic panel produces a 24-hour average of 13 W/m², which is what a friend of mine in England is getting, you need about 16 square meters of photovoltaic panels to power the device, which costs about US$2000 at this point. That's well within the bounds of feasibility, although it's a big enough asset to be a temptation to thieves.

So when you say, "I feel like I'm missing something here," I agree: you were missing quantitative understanding of the subject, and as a result your quantitative conclusions were completely wrong, even though they were based on correct qualitative understanding.

Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by zzalpha on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:24PM (#11434057)
So for one person you'd need $2000 worth of solar panels, 16 square meters of panel.

One person.

It seems like you've supported my point, not refuted it.

But I appreciate your analysis, even if I dispute your conclusion! Thanks!

Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by kragen on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @12:31PM (#11439839)
Does US$2000 per person for the energy to solve the potable water problem for 30 years seem like a lot to you? Compared to the cost of other survival necessities (housing, food, sanitation, heating, cooling — http://resiliencemaps.org/) it's quite reasonable. 16 m² is also pretty small compared to the space customarily used for housing.

However, I made an error! It turns out I left out the coefficient of performance in my calculations. So it's actually 105 watts, 8 m², and about US$1000:

    You have: (8 liters / day) * (41 kJ / mol) / (18 g / mol) * (1 g / cc)
    You want: W
            * 210.90535
            / 0.0047414634
    You have: (8 liters / day) * (41 kJ / mol) / (18 g / mol) * (1 g / cc) / 2
    You want: W
            * 105.45267
            / 0.0094829268
    You have: (8 liters / day) * (41 kJ / mol) / (18 g / mol) * (1 g / cc) / 2 / (13 W / m^2)
    You want: m^2
            * 8.1117442
            / 0.12327805
My guess of US$1000 for 8 m² is based on my guess that 8 m² is about 8000 watts of solar constant, and at 16% efficiency that's 1280 peak watts, and people quote PV modules as below US$1/watt, which I assume is a peak watt. The actual price right now is about US$0.55/watt, depending on where you are, so a more precise estimate is actually US$700:

    You have: 8000 watts * 16% * $ 0.55/watt
    You want: 
    	Definition: 704 US$
My friend who's getting those 13 W/m² has her panels in England, though. So that's kind of a worst-case number. You'd need a fraction of that (like, say, 20% or so) in an equatorial desert.

If PV modules return to their previous price trend (they were dropping fairly smoothly by 36% per year in 2010-2013, but have been nearly plateaued since hitting grid parity in much of the world in 2013 and therefore having a hard time with capacity keeping up with demand) then they'd drop by another factor of 4. The Credit Suisse doc posted earlier today to HN https://doc.research-and-analytics.csfb.com/docView?sourceid... about how we are now in a "solar manufacturing oversupply" situation suggests that something like that might actually happen. Like what happened to DRAM prices in 1996 after the price-fixing cartel collapsed and they went from $40 a meg to $10 a meg almost overnight.

Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by msandford on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:50PM (#11434290)
It's kind of like the Tesla, which people think is amazing. For $90k you could also buy a $60k car and $30k worth of gasoline up-front and tada! you can now refuel it for free or almost free (it takes a little energy to pump the gas out of the underground storage tank and into your car's gas tank).
Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @01:55PM (#11432718)
Love your math. Something to consider is the excessive amount of wind power being generated in certain parts of the world right now. If you can't move that power somewhere, could use it to extract fresh water from the atmosphere rather than curtail production.
Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by clayrichardson on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @02:22PM (#11432973)
That is awesome! We'd love to have a chat with you to better understand your thinking process, perspective, and sources.

The pump were using right now consumes 104 W intermittently. For our next prototype, we're going to use a condenser unit from a walk-in freezer (1168W), a split A/C unit to pretreat the air (560W) MinnowBoardMax (15W), duct fan (208W), etc.

Re:Show HN: Open-source atmospheric water generator – first ... by kragen on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @12:32PM (#11439845)
Awesome! I'd totally be up for chatting. How much water does it produce?