Re:Determining Gender of a Name with 80% Accuracy Using Only...
by onion2k on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:23AM
(#11428518)
The point still stands though - guessing a user's gender based on their name whatever solution you use will get it wrong every time the user doesn't identify with the normative gender for that given name. It's much more user friendly to ask (and include an option for "Prefer not to say").
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Determining Gender of a Name with 80% Accuracy Using Only...
by LyndsySimon on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:06PM
(#11433362)
> get it wrong every time the user doesn't identify with the normative gender for that given name
While I'm not really buying your root argument, this statement is spot on.
Case in point - I'm a man named Lyndsy.
Re:Determining Gender of a Name with 80% Accuracy Using Only...
by cjslep on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:31AM
(#11428559)
Serious question: How can a name have a biological sex? (Wouldn't the fact that penis-people and vagina-people could be named Amy, but society heavily biases towards one, imply names are indicators of societal genders and not biological sex?)
I agree with your above points about the dangers of making guesses on gender. I'm just not well versed in the progressive gender concepts and don't understand the semantics you are arguing for.
Re:Determining Gender of a Name with 80% Accuracy Using Only...
by jacalata on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:36AM
(#11428794)
I think that by 'biological sex' they are saying it is identifying the gender of the person as it was assigned to them at birth, which is usually based on visible biological sex characteristics.
Re:Determining Gender of a Name with 80% Accuracy Using Only...
by profmonocle on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:37AM
(#11428579)
No one is suggesting this should be done in actual production software - even the author says it's just "an easy project to learn machine learning".
I appreciate the point you're trying to make, but it's kind of a straw man argument.