Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by seven on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:01AM
(#1142769)
I do not see why to put 'wasted' in quotes.
I am always shocked to see how many people, who should know better, fall for the homeopathy scam. Some do believe that it is 'medicine with natural ingredients' and start to argue that our modern medicine is based on the natural medicine.
While this is true, it has nothing to do with homeopathy. The concept of homeopathy is fundamentally flawed and is based on crazy pseudo science.
Then there is this 'but if it helps with the placebo effect it is not that bad' argument. It is that bad because some people put too much faith into it and try to cure for example Malaria with sugar pills. It wont work. People will die.
I am just shocked that this stuff is still available in 2010...
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by rauljara on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:37AM
(#1142855)
The BBC's common practice is to put quotes around headline elements that are, in fact, quotes. The House of Commons Science and Technology Committee are the ones making the claim that said the money is wasted, and the headline title is quoting them.
It took me a while to get used to that practice, myself. After years of reading American headlines, a lot of BBC headlines look like they are trying to be ironic or something.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by eli on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:45AM
(#1142876)
Right, they're called "scare quotes."
It's not meant to convey irony, just that the accusation that the money was wasted is not an objectively verifiable fact and, anyway, that the BBC itself does not necessarily agree with that characterization.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by timthorn on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:10AM
(#1142948)
No, this isn't saying that the accusation is not an objectively verifiable fact, simply that it's not the BBC stating it. These are quotes being used as they are meant to be.
Cure is in quotes because it's not yet proven that the technique is indeed a cure. Not because the BBC wants to give proper credit to whichever person called it a cure.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by timthorn on Monday February 22, 2010 @12:28PM
(#1143162)
It's not news that money spent on homeopathy is wasted (saving for placebo effects, etc). It's news because the Select Committee has said so, and the quotes are needed to attribute the claim to a third party.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by Roridge on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:24AM
(#1142827)
This isn't just a few people who "fell for homoeopathy" this is an entire countries health system, where Dr's will have prescribed homoeopathy to patients. Hence why wasted is in quotes.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by axod on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:31AM
(#1142841)
Let's be honest here. It's not an "ENTIRE" countries health system.
The NHS funds a few small homoeopathy clinics.
I would be extremely surprised if any GP has 'prescribed homoeopathy'. I'm sure it's almost always the case that the patient asks/demands to be prescribed it because they've read/heard something about it, or conventional medicine just isn't working for them.
As the NHS is publicly owned, it has to try and please most people. If a segment of society believe in alternative medicine, unfortunately it's going to be hard to tell them "Yes, you pay your taxes for healthcare, but we do not believe in alternative medicine, so we will not provide it for you".
At the end of the day though this is a ridiculously small % of people, and a ridiculously small amount of money compared to the full NHS budget.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by Roridge on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:03AM
(#1142931)
Being able to "vote" on something is not the same as owning something.
>> There's a difference between a GP suggesting homoeopathy, and a GP refering a patient after the patient has requested homoeopathy.
That is a fair point, but you can't say for sure that a GP hasn't perscribed or refered someone for this treatment. So kind of irrelevant.
But it remains that the HNS wasted the money. As you yourself pointed out they didn't put it to good use because they spent it on homeopathy. Anything not put to good use is wasted is it not?
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by axod on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:50AM
(#1143066)
It's probably more useful to look at real scandalous waste, like the computer system:
"Delays to NHS computer system could cost taxpayers £40bn"
I'm not saying the £4m isn't important, but it's not massive compared to their budget. They could likely have cut down on using temp staff, and saved that £4m easily enough.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by Roridge on Monday February 22, 2010 @01:13PM
(#1143300)
I can't see your original comment above, but I am sure you were talking about why they had put 'wasted' in quotes, and that you felt homoeopathic medicine was a waste of time, so your last comment is quite off topic.
However, while it may be debatable the NHS is one of the best things the UK has (I can introduce you to many NHS workers who disagree) that be it £4million or £40 billion wasted, wasted is wasted, and that's why the BBC article put it in quotes. Because any wasted money in a government organisation costs jobs.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by CWuestefeld on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:07AM
(#1142795)
If the homeopaths could just prove that it works, James Randi would give them $1million, free and clear.
Sceptic James Randi is so convinced that homeopathy will not work, that he has offered $1m to anyone who can provide convincing evidence of its effects.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by idleworx on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:26AM
(#1142998)
Please stop it with the James Randi defense. He's just as biased as the people he claims to investigate. He's a pseudo-skeptic as much as a pseudoscientist is a pseudoscientist. Just because Randi is offering 1million $ for anything is not proof that homeopathy (or anything else for that matter works).
http://www.sfweekly.com/2009-08-26/news/the-demystifying-adv...
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by isleyaardvark on Monday February 22, 2010 @12:37PM
(#1143184)
I read the article at your link and I thought it was quite complimentary to Mr. Randi. Furthermore, the description of the test in that article didn't leave much room for bias to have an effect.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by billpg on Monday February 22, 2010 @02:53PM
(#1143552)
I make the sun raise every morning.
No, seriously. Every morning, I wake up and the sun has risen. Clearly I made it happen. It happens while I'm asleep so it can't have been the placebo effect.
for information about United States federal funding of "alternative medicine" research. I think homeopathy is not as routinely covered by health insurance in the United States as in some other countries, but of course the insurance system in the United States is not really a national system at all, but a collection of varied private contracts state by state.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by djhomeless on Monday February 22, 2010 @11:42AM
(#1143044)
I've used homeopathy here in the UK and it does work. However, I seriously doubt any GP here would refer someone to a homeopath unless already suggested by the patient. Different strokes for different folks you know? It's not for everyone.
Personally though, I prefer acupuncture, which is also available via the NHS.
Re: NHS money 'wasted' on homeopathy
by seven on Monday February 22, 2010 @12:12PM
(#1143122)
Just because you got ill, used homeopathy and then got better, does not mean that homeopathy does work. Not even if the same happened to your uncle and your brother in law.
Science is currently the best way we have to look at the world from a not that subjective perspective. Homeopathy does no better than the placebo effect. If something claims to 'work'.. then I expect it to 'work' better than a placebo. Homeopathy is not better. Not a bit.
Believe me, I would be very happy if some of the pseudo science stuff would work. Live would be great!
I am always shocked to see how many people, who should know better, fall for the homeopathy scam. Some do believe that it is 'medicine with natural ingredients' and start to argue that our modern medicine is based on the natural medicine. While this is true, it has nothing to do with homeopathy. The concept of homeopathy is fundamentally flawed and is based on crazy pseudo science.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy
Then there is this 'but if it helps with the placebo effect it is not that bad' argument. It is that bad because some people put too much faith into it and try to cure for example Malaria with sugar pills. It wont work. People will die.
I am just shocked that this stuff is still available in 2010...
It took me a while to get used to that practice, myself. After years of reading American headlines, a lot of BBC headlines look like they are trying to be ironic or something.
It's not meant to convey irony, just that the accusation that the money was wasted is not an objectively verifiable fact and, anyway, that the BBC itself does not necessarily agree with that characterization.
Scare quotes can be used to quote a person and to provide distance from their words
Look at another example off the homepage: Hope over peanut allergy 'cure' http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7899383.stm
Cure is in quotes because it's not yet proven that the technique is indeed a cure. Not because the BBC wants to give proper credit to whichever person called it a cure.
Sure you can call them scare quotes but these quotes can be used for various reasons, I'm pretty sure as a news organisation the BBC intended use–mention distinction: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use%E2%80%93mention_distinction
They occasionally be used for other reasons like jargon.
The NHS funds a few small homoeopathy clinics.
I would be extremely surprised if any GP has 'prescribed homoeopathy'. I'm sure it's almost always the case that the patient asks/demands to be prescribed it because they've read/heard something about it, or conventional medicine just isn't working for them.
As the NHS is publicly owned, it has to try and please most people. If a segment of society believe in alternative medicine, unfortunately it's going to be hard to tell them "Yes, you pay your taxes for healthcare, but we do not believe in alternative medicine, so we will not provide it for you".
At the end of the day though this is a ridiculously small % of people, and a ridiculously small amount of money compared to the full NHS budget.
It is thought about £4m a year is spent on homeopathy by the NHS
Compare that to the total funding of NHS, roughly £100 billion.
What part of the NHS in the UK is publicly owned? I pay my NI the same as everyone, but they never asked me as an owner what I felt about it.
>> "but they never asked me as an owner what I felt about it."
You get to vote. You get to write to your MP, your local hospital, etc etc.
>> There's a difference between a GP suggesting homoeopathy, and a GP refering a patient after the patient has requested homoeopathy.
That is a fair point, but you can't say for sure that a GP hasn't perscribed or refered someone for this treatment. So kind of irrelevant.
But it remains that the HNS wasted the money. As you yourself pointed out they didn't put it to good use because they spent it on homeopathy. Anything not put to good use is wasted is it not?
Sure, waste is waste, but the amount is tiny.
"Delays to NHS computer system could cost taxpayers £40bn"
I'm not saying the £4m isn't important, but it's not massive compared to their budget. They could likely have cut down on using temp staff, and saved that £4m easily enough.
The NHS is one of the best things the UK has. We pay far less for our healthcare than the US, and enjoy longer life.
It's not all bad. Any large system has wastage, it's just a part of being big.
However, while it may be debatable the NHS is one of the best things the UK has (I can introduce you to many NHS workers who disagree) that be it £4million or £40 billion wasted, wasted is wasted, and that's why the BBC article put it in quotes. Because any wasted money in a government organisation costs jobs.
Sceptic James Randi is so convinced that homeopathy will not work, that he has offered $1m to anyone who can provide convincing evidence of its effects.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2002/homeopathy.shtml
They don't even have to demonstrate it works, just that you can tell homeopathy from water.
Medicine.
No, seriously. Every morning, I wake up and the sun has risen. Clearly I made it happen. It happens while I'm asleep so it can't have been the placebo effect.
http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=3344
for information about United States federal funding of "alternative medicine" research. I think homeopathy is not as routinely covered by health insurance in the United States as in some other countries, but of course the insurance system in the United States is not really a national system at all, but a collection of varied private contracts state by state.
Personally though, I prefer acupuncture, which is also available via the NHS.
Science is currently the best way we have to look at the world from a not that subjective perspective. Homeopathy does no better than the placebo effect. If something claims to 'work'.. then I expect it to 'work' better than a placebo. Homeopathy is not better. Not a bit.
Believe me, I would be very happy if some of the pseudo science stuff would work. Live would be great!
edit: fixed typo