News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The next twenty years are going to be completely unlike t... by _delirium on Monday February 22, 2010 @05:17AM (#1142369)
This feels a little too gold-buggish for me in parts. Fiat money and fractional-reserve banking are quite separate things: fractional-reserve banking was common even with gold currency. Unless an intrusive government regulation outlaws people from accepting deposits and lending them back out, and even further, from issuing promissory notes, it will continue to happen even in a gold-standard economy, because full-reserve banks are less attractive, both to owners and depositors, except in crises, of which our memories are short.

Gold supply also has over the past 100 years or so inflated at a low exponential curve that looks much like a compounding curve, because the annual production has been increasing roughly in line with the total amount in existence (from 400 tons/yr in 1900 to 2500 tons/yr today). It's compounding with a low rate, around 1%-2% over most of that period, but nonethless the money supply inflates, and continues to inflate faster in absolute terms year to year (with some dips now and then).

Re:The next twenty years are going to be completely unlike t... by nazgulnarsil on Monday February 22, 2010 @06:40AM (#1142437)
actually they are connected. with a gold standard banks that run FRB risk actual bank runs. with a fiat system the government (fed) can provide unlimited backing so instead of a bank run the fed would print money, causing inflation (see the Savings and Loan crisis of the 80's). your buying power decreases in exchange for socializing the risk of bank runs.

one of the reasons austrians bug me is their insistence on 100% reserve banking even though a cursory examination of history reveals that there is market demand for FRB. sure, demand would certainly be lower than it is now if there was no "lender of last resort" fed subsidizing risk, but it would still exist. most people care about 100% safe investments.

however the austrian criticism that banks who mismanage their funds should be allowed to fail is spot on.

Re:The next twenty years are going to be completely unlike t... by _delirium on Monday February 22, 2010 @08:00AM (#1142545)
Yeah, there's more scope to maneuver in a fiat-money system; I was mainly objecting to what seemed to be the suggestion that under a gold standard FRB and the money multiplier somehow wouldn't exist. It seems that some people in this group want to somehow mandate that everyone conduct their transactions by literally exchanging gold coins in bags. But the people with that viewpoint tend to also be libertarians... how, consistent with libertarianism, can the government prohibit private individuals from exchanging pieces of paper saying "I owe you 5 ounces of gold", and force them to physically exchange the 5 ounces of gold instead? But if the government doesn't force them to physically exchange the gold, you have a money multiplier, and, in effect, privately minted fiat currency. And the related bubbles and crashes would also exist, as they have for centuries.
Re:The next twenty years are going to be completely unlike t... by nazgulnarsil on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:10AM (#1142801)
Re:The next twenty years are going to be completely unlike t... by splat on Monday February 22, 2010 @08:54AM (#1142610)
I was under the impression that there has been a variety of opinions concerning fractional-reserve banking in the Austrian School. While Rothbard was fervently opposed to it and Mises was hostile to it, I know that Hayek, at least, believed a fractional-reserve banking system to be necessary for an efficient economy.
Re:The next twenty years are going to be completely unlike t... by nazgulnarsil on Monday February 22, 2010 @10:09AM (#1142797)
it seems to me like the vast majority of modern austrians are basically rothbardians.