Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by Kequc on Sunday April 03, 2016 @06:39PM
(#11418132)
Even Gmail, what I would consider a gold standard, only allows letters, numbers, and periods. So when you're done accusing me of not being someone viable for a position anywhere important maybe you should send a message outlining the same argument to Google.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:It's Impossible to Validate an Email Address
by Spivak on Sunday April 03, 2016 @07:33PM
(#11418381)
Huh, Gmail completely implements RFC5321 and you can send and receive email from any valid address, even from their web client, and they validate the email address.
I stand by my position, failing to implement the spec correctly should be considered an error even when Google does it.
If you want a compromise, how about printing "we don't support email addresses with X" if you want to be picky for SPAM detection, simplicity, or something rather than "this email address isn't valid." Google does this for some valid-but-not-accepted addresses on their signup page but it's not sophisticated enough to catch everything.