Re:The TSA Randomizer App Cost $336k
by agf on Sunday April 03, 2016 @05:34PM
(#11417865)
I doubt this was meant seriously, but it's worth noting this actually doesn't work. You need each left/right decision to be independent so that positioning yourself at a certain place in line doesn't allow you to choose left/right.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
So you're saying this app operated by TSA agents is meant to defeat attackers looking to be screened by cooperative TSA agents? I can't help but feel something is lacking in this threat model.
I'm not sure I understand this. If I were to observe the pattern before I reach the agent, it would be easy enough to let someone go ahead of me while pretending to finish a phone call or something. It doesn't require the cooperation of the TSA agent.
Defense in depth is a real thing.
More and more it seems to me that there is no replacement for correctness, and you have to squint to tell this apart from theater.
Perhaps I'm exaggerating. It would certainly raise costs to the attacker to recruit an additional collaborator, and to wait for a serendipitous scheduling. But I'm not convinced it raises the difficulty by $300k.