News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by lizzard on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:54AM (#11416304)
Hi. I'm someone's mom, and both of us understand this. When you use mothers as a metonym for people who don't understand technology, think about who you are assuming is your audience, and who are you are excluding and insulting.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by smt88 on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:51AM (#11416509)
Suggesting that moms aren't tech savvy is not only harmful and bigoted, it's also misinformed.

Many vital, important moms were pioneers in computing. My mom taught me how to use a computer and write code, and she was self-taught.

Part of the implication here is that the people who are more likely to handle domestic work are likely less intelligent. That's bullshit.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:21PM (#11416610)
My mom is not tech savvy.

Can I get your permission to laugh at the link's title or do I need to be wildly offended?

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by clbrook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:28PM (#11416640)
I think it seems appropriate to laugh (especially since it pertains in your particular life) and at the same time understand and appreciate what sort of societal stereotypes it perpetuates, which might then contribute toward less women desiring to participate in technology communities.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:35PM (#11416668)
Personally, I am much more bothered by the caustic atmosphere created by the overly Politically Correct backlash when an insignificant implication is made...
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:43PM (#11416698)
The environment is caustic in large part because you're pouring lye onto it.

Someone took a moment to explain --- very correctly --- that using "mom" as a metonym for "technically naive" is inaccurate, dismissive, and exclusionary. That comment didn't accuse anyone of intending to do any of that. It simply pointed out the outcome of the wording. The very same comment could have been written about "grandfather" and ageism.

Nobody asked you to be offended, or to take offense.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by locopati on Monday April 04, 2016 @01:57PM (#11423881)
Perhaps the implication is not actually insignificant.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:39PM (#11416684)
Nobody has asked you to be "wildly offended". Please stop.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:46PM (#11416713)
I thought that if so many were being offended on the behalf of others (women, parents, elderly, I dunno), the implication was that there was something that needed attention.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:52PM (#11416735)
Due respect, but who do you think you're kidding? Use your browser, hit CMD-F (or whatever), type "offen", and grep through the thread to see who's using that word.

Now pay attention to the timestamps and see who's introducing it. The only person to use the word before you was carefully explaining that they were not taking offense. You responded to them by accusing them of being "primed and ready".

Please, please stop doing this to HN threads. What you're doing on this one is poisonous.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @01:09PM (#11416789)
Top thread refers the title being "insulting", which is what set this whole thing in motion.

I am not ranting & raving. I am having a logical conversation. Stop treating me like I am out of control. I am happy to have a logical conversation, but your numerous "please, please stop" replies are non-contributory and demeaning, so... please stop. :)

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @01:19PM (#11416812)
I didn't accuse you of "ranting and raving".
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @01:38PM (#11416875)
No, you just said my posts were poisonous and you repeatedly begged me to stop, which is completely unconstructive criticism, bordering on plain old insults, which I never resorted to.

Just because I disagree with you, you think you can bully me with nonsense rather than having a conversation? Whatever. You win.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by carbocation on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:23AM (#11416405)
I agree with you. Thinking of alternative phrases, perhaps "neophyte," "uninitiated," or "a smart child" would work.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by junke on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:33AM (#11416454)
What about "your legislator". It is what matters, after all.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by munin on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:25AM (#11416412)
what about "anyone?"
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by evook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:24AM (#11416409)
Who cares?
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by clbrook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:25AM (#11416416)
I do.

I was pleased when I opened the comment section to see this as the top comment.

I want to live in a world where being kind, respectful, understanding, and caring are the highest of virtues. In that world, hopefully all people will work toward working together to understand others and appreciate our many wonderful differences instead of insulting them, even in a micro-aggression, this might be funny, yet deprecating sort of way.

Although I personally don't often spend much time being offended by these culturally accepted deprecating statements, I have recently started to wonder if it is contributing toward the public policies that attempt to marginalize and discriminate against any group of people.

Moms build things. Girls build things. Women build things. I build things.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:54AM (#11416517)
Does being kind & understanding mean allowing someone to make a joke about you? I often allow jokes at my expense if the intent was not malicious.

Also, I perceived the joke to be making fun of the elderly, not women. Honestly, you post seems like you were primed & ready to be offended by the slightest thing, which has more negative social impact than the light-hearted title of the linked article.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by clbrook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:16PM (#11416589)
Interesting. I think it is unlikely that most people would consider me easily offended.

If it wasn't historically pervasive, yet false to declare that women are not tech savvy, I likely would not have said anything, however, this is a technology focused community and thus it seems relevant to not promote that unfortunate typecast.

I was unaware that Moms were considered elderly - I had my first child at 25, is that old? I guess that's another case in point why not to use 'Mom' in this sense, it comes off insulting to some and also is perceived to mean multiple, possibly unintended things.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:26PM (#11416633)
I make a point to attempt being offended only when I am sure that offense was intended.

Look for ways to be offended, or look for ways to understand. You seem to be doing the former, which is wasteful.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by clbrook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:36PM (#11416670)
I think your assessment of my intent and approach are incorrect.

I fear we are entering the spiral of pointing fingers at one another.

As a mother and thoughtful human being, this is when I would suggest to my children they walk away from the situation at hand and I will thus follow my own advice.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:59PM (#11416756)
Your comments here have been both graceful and extraordinarily polite, given the circumstances. Thank you!
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:43PM (#11416705)
Why would it be OK to make fun of the elderly? Why would you stick up for that?

Also, the person to whom you're responding had, when you wrote this, one carefully worded comment on the thread. "Primed and ready"? Clearly, the person on the thread most fitting that description is you. Please stop doing this.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by forgetsusername on Sunday April 03, 2016 @10:46PM (#11419086)
We make fun of all sorts of people in life. I even do so at my own expense. Its not a big deal; it's even referred to as fun.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:54PM (#11416741)
My comment about the elderly was intended to show that the poster was overly focused sexism when the title may have been referencing ageism or perhaps something else or perhaps nothing negative at all.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by evook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:50AM (#11416508)
> I want to live in a world where being kind, respectful, understanding, and caring are the highest of virtues.

That's cool and stuff, but the humankind as a huge organism doesn't work like this and will never as long as we don't start genetically modify humans at scale to be engineered that way when hatched. We're still just "animals" or low-power carbon based computers if you prefer that phrasing.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by Blahah on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:30AM (#11416441)
I do. I care about people. I care about making people feel welcome in communities I take part in.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:06PM (#11416556)
I do not give you permission to be offended on my behalf.

Any jokes about my particular demographic will be allowed without criticism and I may even laugh at the joke myself.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by fucking_tragedy on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:41AM (#11416480)
Otherizing and implying that people, based on their gender or family relations, can't comprehend technology is wrong.

It's a reason tech was/is a boys' club for men and has kept talented people from contributing to the field.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by gemma on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:35AM (#11416457)
Me.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:40AM (#11416478)
You are offended by sexism?

I only see ageism.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by forgetsusername on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:04AM (#11416331)
>who are you are excluding and insulting.

Change it to Dad then. I'm someone's Dad, have a Dad, and none of us feel excluded or insulted. It's a figure of speech.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by Blahah on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:39AM (#11416473)
You don't speak on behalf of dads generally. I'm a dad, and would be insulted if the word chosen was dad.

Singling out some group as symbolic of something negative (in this case, ignorance about technical matters), is unnecessary and likely to offend.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:11PM (#11416571)
What's offensive about being ignorant of technical matters?
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by tptacek on Sunday April 03, 2016 @12:46PM (#11416714)
Obviously, because that creates the presumption that the thoughts and opinions of dads (or moms, or grandfathers, or whatever) regarding technology can be dismissed.

Ask a simple question, get a simple answer.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by bcook on Sunday April 03, 2016 @01:24PM (#11416828)
I always thought a statement of someone's ignorance was more or less a statement of fact, vs questioning someone's abilities or intelligence, which are considered insults.

Whether the implication was intended to be negative... I dunno.

Sorry about my sub-par manners today.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by smt88 on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:46AM (#11416496)
"Figure of speech" isn't a defense against something being harmful. "That's very white of you" used to be an expression in the South in the US, where "white" meant "good". (It's now changed to me, "That's very Christian of you.")
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by SNvD7vEJ on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:23AM (#11416404)
LOL, this is one ignorant defense.
Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by forgetsusername on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:29AM (#11416439)
>LOL, this is one ignorant defense.

So, saying you're a Mom and offended is a valid argument, but that you're a Dad and not offended isn't?

Yep, that sounds about right for one of these arguments.

Re:Why metadata is bad – 3 minute video your Mom will unders... by dllthomas on Sunday April 03, 2016 @11:47AM (#11416499)
Saying you are a mom (or dad) and are offended is a valid argument that offence is occurring. Saying you are a dad (or mom) and are not offended is not a valid argument that offence is not occurring.

Sounds right for any rational argument.

Of course, having established that offence is occurring, it still leaves open what the appropriate response is.